Re:The Mercenaries: Ex-NSA hackers are shaping the future of...
by tedunangst on Thursday November 13, 2014 @12:55PM
(#8602899)
Such a ban would presumably put Veracode out of business as well, since such tools could easily be weaponized to find vulns in other peoples software.
Re:The Mercenaries: Ex-NSA hackers are shaping the future of...
by tptacek on Thursday November 13, 2014 @01:24PM
(#8603078)
So it wouldn't be ALL bad. :P
(KIDDING, CHRISSES.)
Re:The Mercenaries: Ex-NSA hackers are shaping the future of...
by raesene4 on Thursday November 13, 2014 @11:05AM
(#8602224)
well I'm not a legislator, and if you're looking to pick holes, trust me you would be able to :)
The question is, is that the best approach and if not, what is? Once an approach is agreed then the inevitable x years of wrangling on details could occur.
Re:The Mercenaries: Ex-NSA hackers are shaping the future of...
by tptacek on Thursday November 13, 2014 @11:06AM
(#8602234)
You are crazy if you think that legislators are going to do a better job of designing a policy to regulate vulnerability researchers than technologists will. Whatever the policy would end up being, it will be asymptotically as effective and reasonable as whatever we talk about here.
If a bunch of technologists (including vuln researchers) can't define a reasonable policy, I think it's a pretty safe bet that there's no reasonable policy to be had.
Re:The Mercenaries: Ex-NSA hackers are shaping the future of...
by raesene4 on Thursday November 13, 2014 @11:28AM
(#8602371)
Well I did say at the top of this thread that the proposal had glaring problems :) I was interested to hear if other people had alternate suggestions which would address the issue.
Re:The Mercenaries: Ex-NSA hackers are shaping the future of...
by tedunangst on Thursday November 13, 2014 @02:19PM
(#8603440)
Sure. "It's not an issue." Problem solved.
O.K., so if I find an RCE in Windows 10, I have to sell it to Microsoft. But if I don't like the price I'm going to get from Microsoft, why wouldn't I just not independently find RCEs in Windows 10, and instead just sell engineering services to non-Microsoft companies who want to find and exploit those vulnerabilities themselves?
Obviously, you'd want to ban that kind of service. But how would you do that? What does that ban look like? A ban on reverse engineering? How do you differentiate the kind of reversing that Tridge did to build Samba from the kind of reversing HD Moore's team does to build Metasploit? Also: you want to ban Metasploit?