News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Mercenaries: Ex-NSA hackers are shaping the future of... by tptacek on Thursday November 13, 2014 @09:18AM (#8601576)
"A survey of 181 attendees at the 2012 Black Hat USA conference in Las Vegas found that 36 percent of “information security professionals” said they’d engaged in retaliatory hack-backs."

What? Black Hat attendance is in the high thousands. A plurality of those attending are IT professionals --- people that wouldn't have the technical capability to take over a botnet even if they wanted to. Even if you broadened the definition of "hacking back", as some people do, to recon activities like port scans. No part of this anecdote makes sense.

For my part (I'm a security researcher by background, though that's not what I'm doing now, and I've presented at Black Hat numerous times): not only have I never met a professional who claimed to have "hacked back" anything, but I've never even met one who didn't think that was a crazy idea.

There is a difference between major organized efforts to bring down botnets and "hackback" the way the term gets associated with Endgame.

Re:The Mercenaries: Ex-NSA hackers are shaping the future of... by sarciszewski on Thursday November 13, 2014 @11:01AM (#8602198)
> I never met a professional who claimed to have "hacked back" anything, but I've never even met one who didn't think that was a crazy idea.

Coming from the amateur side of things, my observations mirror your observations. The only people who think it's a good idea, from what I've seen, are script kiddies-- not professionals.