Thanks for your feedback. The thing about permissions being an install time decision is also what makes me weary about Android - I imagine it would happen quite often that I have to make a decision between using an App that would be really useful or even required right now and giving it my addresses, which I really don't want. That's something iOS does much better and I wonder how much of a downside it would be in real life usage.
Re:Android 5.0 Lollipop reviewed
by Brakenshire on Thursday November 13, 2014 @03:44AM
(#8600526)
> seems like 70% of apps I try to install wants access to my contacts at install-time
How does iOS handle this?
Not parent, but: it asks for every permission separately at runtime (on first time usage). That might seem a hassle, but IMO it's much better this way. Apps tend to be much more conservative in order to not disturb their users too much with permission questions, and they also have fallback modes for every permission that's not critical - a Maps app will still work without location data for example.
Re:Android 5.0 Lollipop reviewed
by wlesieutre on Thursday November 13, 2014 @10:38AM
(#8602024)
To give an example, consider a document scanning app that has a feature where you can sign up for a DocuScans account and use it to share scanned documents with other people who use the same app.
A useless feature, as far as I'm concerned. But on Android, the app will demand access to all of my contacts at install time, just in case I ever wanted to use it. And then I have no idea what else they might be doing with it.
On iOS, the app doesn't have permission to get my contacts until it asks for it. Using Dropbox for your scanned documents instead of the DocuScans sharing system? Then the app will never request permission to access your contacts.
Re:Android 5.0 Lollipop reviewed
by ErikHuisman on Thursday November 13, 2014 @03:51AM
(#8600550)
Issues a permission confirmation the moment the app tries to access contacts (once).
I can totally understand why people for various reasons would like not be in Apple's walled garden or don't like how Apple things work. But Android is a very poor alternative. It doesn't give us the truly open system that we as users deserve. It has a horrible broken ecosystem in regards to privacy, design and annoyance (ads, ads everywhere). Google enforces their own products beyond just "hey look at this cool youtube thing" in a way that is much beyond what Apple does.
Yes I do really like stuff Apple produces but was really looking forward to use an open mobile OS. But the whole experience with Android and Google has left me very negative to use anything from Google again.