I think your first paragraph contains a non sequitur. The existence of the strict and warnings pragmas, Perl::Critic, Perl::Tidy, Test::More, the size of the bundled perldoc, CPAN testers, CPANTS, et al all contribute to the maintainability of Perl 5 applications.
If you choose not to take advantage of those tools when writing a Perl 5 application, you bear the risk yourself. How does that reflect on the language or the ecosystem?
Pretty much everyone I work with has been burned by being handed some legacy Perl to maintain and as a result we are very reluctant to do any new work with it. The payoff for rewriting in Python is that the technical debt incurred for using Perl in the first place is repaid.