News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Rejected for a Job at the Container Store by toomuchtodo on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @03:32PM (#8597945)
I've always wondered if basic income would remove the need for VCs; everyone in your startup is essentially fully funded then (as long as you didn't need to live in an expensive locale) and your only cost is AWS (or whatever infrastructure provider you're running on).
Re:Rejected for a Job at the Container Store by jonlucc on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @03:35PM (#8597968)
Or perhaps VCs would shift to more expensive fields like hardware, internet of things types of projects.
Re:Rejected for a Job at the Container Store by toomuchtodo on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @03:59PM (#8598115)
Definitely this. They'd move to capital-intensive projects (Tesla, SpaceX, etc).
Re:Rejected for a Job at the Container Store by briandear on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @04:54PM (#8598489)
Who pays for that basic income? The guy that's working 60 hours at a job he hates because he's trying to be personally responsible. If we had 'basic income' what would be the incentive to work at all? High unemployment is correlated to higher basic income availability. The EU unemployment rate is almost double that if the US. Even progressive Sweeden has an 8% rate. China, incidentally has a 4% rate.

Incentives are powerful things and the law of unintended consequences ought to ignored at our own peril.

Re:Rejected for a Job at the Container Store by toomuchtodo on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @05:04PM (#8598565)
The point of basic income is to pay for it with automation and software, not the sweat and blood of someone else.

The majority of farming can be automated. Should it not be possible to give food away for nothing then? If trucking/mobility (self driving cars) can provide such a huge benefit to society, why would we not provide it at almost no cost to people?

Robotics. Software. Renewable Energy. These three ingredients remove the need to take anything from anyone while providing for everyone.

You're still going to need to work to get your latest film or Taylor Swift album if you have moral qualms about IP rights, but we are slowly approaching the age where we have enough energy and the required framework to meet everyone's basic needs without taking from that 60 hour/week fellow.

To your point, the unemployment rate SHOULD be high. People do not live to work, they work to live. The sooner we can let everyone have more leisure time and not die from starvation or lack of medical care, the sooner we advance as a people.

In closing, think like an engineer. The incentive to work should be, "How can I fix or automate this problem so a human being never needs to work on it again?"

Re:Rejected for a Job at the Container Store by zo1 on Friday November 14, 2014 @09:02AM (#8607116)
Unfortunately, our society isn't structured that way at the moment. Any benefit gained from automation is not directly "transferred" to some arbitrary bucket designated "Money we can now spend on enhancing peoples lives / making it so they don't work for basic needs."

>"Robotics. Software. Renewable Energy. These three ingredients remove the need to take anything from anyone while providing for everyone."

As much as I admire your noble sentiment, I feel it is a bit unrealistic. Someone has to pay for those robots to be designed, maintained. For that software to be designed and administered, monitored. And renewable energy doesn't manifest out of nowhere, it needs capital investment (most of the time) to be harnessed.

I'm struggling to conceptually understand how you think those items will manufacture productivity (general concept, as opposed to money) without it being taken from someone, whether willingly or forcefully?

Re:Rejected for a Job at the Container Store by ansible on Thursday November 13, 2014 @10:16AM (#8601888)
The majority of farming can be automated.

The majority of farming already is automated. We've got giant robots that feed us now, they are called tractors. The newest ones have GPS guidance, and literally drive themselves (though they are still required to have a human pilot in the cab). This is a drastically different situation than 100 years ago, with primarily human and animal-powered farming.

The main cost is fuel and other chemical inputs, and the mortgage on the land itself.

Re:Rejected for a Job at the Container Store by zo1 on Friday November 14, 2014 @08:51AM (#8607071)
"The main cost is fuel and other chemical inputs, and the mortgage on the land itself."

Don't forget the capital investment for the actual machines, and the R&D spending required to even make them available. The big reason we do have a lot of our farming automated is because it was profitable to spend upfront capital on automation instead of manual labor which became inefficient/obsolete in that regard.

Re:Rejected for a Job at the Container Store by jessaustin on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @11:00PM (#8599842)
The guy that's working 60 hours at a job he hates...

I've been that guy, but... fuck that guy. Obviously you're not talking about someone who is just barely paying the rent, because overtime. I also presume we're not referring to someone working three part-times; much sympathy in that case, but with EITC how much tax is he really paying? Finally, we must not be talking about the startups, because love.

More likely, this is a salaried employee at an established firm who is doing the job of one-and-a-half or two salaried employees, for the pay and benefits of one. If he started working rationally, the firm would have to hire, and unemployment would decrease.

Re:Rejected for a Job at the Container Store by sanderjd on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @04:20PM (#8598268)
It would probably still make sense to sell some equity for the ability to pay your employees a reasonable salary. Basic income isn't meant to be much.
Re:Rejected for a Job at the Container Store by wutbrodo on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @06:07PM (#8598890)
This effect would be attenuated by the fact that you could pay the equity to employees directly. You are of course correct that for those employees who would rather get a high stable income instead of equity, you would likely need a third-party that was interested in equity alone. But remember that the calculus for stability vs equity would be changed for the employee pool too, so it may simply become the norm to work for equity in a startup.
Re:Rejected for a Job at the Container Store by sanderjd on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @06:24PM (#8598977)
It would definitely change the risk/reward equation, but I think you overestimate how much people value equity vs. living above the poverty line (which is about where basic income would need to be). Or maybe I underestimate it because I don't live in silicon valley. I think basic income would be more exciting for small businesses that aren't attractive to investors, but have similar financial constraints as early-stage startups.
Re:Rejected for a Job at the Container Store by wutbrodo on Friday November 14, 2014 @01:53PM (#8608809)
I may be extrapolating the current situation out too far, but I figure that it'll just sharpen the distinction that already exists between startups and big companies. Right now you can go to a big company and make triple, or you can work for a startup because some combination of the risk/responsibility/potential equity payoff makes up for the loss in salary. I was just extending that idea out further; I already know multiple people who have saved a few 100k a couple years out of college and are much, much less motivated by money now (vs the non-monetary payoffs that startups offer). Sure, the pool of engineers who would do so may be small, but that doesn't mean EVERY startup needs to take this route. Either way, it's an interesting thought.