Re:Who gets the money spent on share buybacks?
by tzs on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @11:39PM
(#8594041)
> The difference between the two is mostly how they are taxed (share buybacks are generally more efficient)
A long time ago a company (I think it was GM, but I'm not sure) got clever. Instead of declaring a dividend, they did something like an 11 for 10 stock split, then did a buyback of 1/11th of the outstanding shares.
The net result is that each shareholder ends up with same number of shares that they had before, and the same fraction of ownership of the company they had before, and they received money from the company in proportion to their share of ownership. It's just like a dividend--except it could be reported as a stock buyback and get treated as capital gains instead of ordinary income.
Because of this, what was once was a short paragraph in the Tax Code is now a couple pages or so, in order to close that loophole without taking capital gains treatment away from legitimate buybacks.
When you gaze at the ~3000 pages of the Tax Code (the widely reported 70k pages is a gross exaggeration) and wonder how it got so big, a good part if of it is because of things like that split/buyback trick. People will put a lot of effort into finding ways to minimize their taxes (rightly so), and so a lot of things have to be specified in great, nit-picky detail, such as how to decide if a buyback is really a buyback or is some kind of disguised dividend or other payment.
A long time ago a company (I think it was GM, but I'm not sure) got clever. Instead of declaring a dividend, they did something like an 11 for 10 stock split, then did a buyback of 1/11th of the outstanding shares.
The net result is that each shareholder ends up with same number of shares that they had before, and the same fraction of ownership of the company they had before, and they received money from the company in proportion to their share of ownership. It's just like a dividend--except it could be reported as a stock buyback and get treated as capital gains instead of ordinary income.
Because of this, what was once was a short paragraph in the Tax Code is now a couple pages or so, in order to close that loophole without taking capital gains treatment away from legitimate buybacks.
When you gaze at the ~3000 pages of the Tax Code (the widely reported 70k pages is a gross exaggeration) and wonder how it got so big, a good part if of it is because of things like that split/buyback trick. People will put a lot of effort into finding ways to minimize their taxes (rightly so), and so a lot of things have to be specified in great, nit-picky detail, such as how to decide if a buyback is really a buyback or is some kind of disguised dividend or other payment.