Re:Who gets the money spent on share buybacks?
by jdmichal on Wednesday November 12, 2014 @12:39AM
(#8594180)
Everything your professor said also applies to dividends. Why are those somehow magically OK when stock buybacks are not? As several others in this thread have explained, both are a net wash.
Instead of investing in R&D, buying assets, streams of income, creating new products, renovating facilities, or even paying your own people, a stock buyback says that all of those things are basically a worse ROI on the business than just handing the money over to shareholders.
In general, I think my professor was right. I think there are good reasons to potentially buy out investors and so on, but usually these programs are done under the guise of making shareholders richer, but I just don't see that as the case.
The best way to enrich shareholders is by simply giving them a dividend, or by running a more profitable business (which will drive up the stock price).
Everything else is basically financial machinations that look good, but are mostly meaningless.