Re:Who gets the money spent on share buybacks?
by pedrocr on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @10:00PM
(#8593772)
> Now you can work your ass off to grow the company, or if manage to convince the right people so you can get those buybacks through, you could go for burning through that cash pile on buybacks, and profit nicely from the resulting rise in share price.
That won't work actually. In an efficient market the share price is unchanged by a share buyback. What will change is earnings per share, as you have the same earnings divided by less shares.
> But it's bad for you if you invest without understanding what is going on. Then again, that's always the case.
If you can get a deal where raising EPS gets you a nice bonus, then sure you can game the system. Those shareholders don't know what they're doing. The shareholders are still the ones that are getting the money from the share buybacks they're just also deciding to give a bonus to management based on flawed metrics.
Say you take control of a company with a nice cash pile from past successes, but that isn't doing too great. You manage to get a great deal of options on the expectation you'll invest that cash pile to grow the business.
Now you can work your ass off to grow the company, or if manage to convince the right people so you can get those buybacks through, you could go for burning through that cash pile on buybacks, and profit nicely from the resulting rise in share price.
And if you're really good at sweet-talking the board, you could manage to sneak in additional options too. After all the share price is rising.
It's mostly a "buyer beware" type thing: It's not good or bad per se. Often the employee stock compensation may be necessary, e.g. to lure fresh blood in. And sometimes buybacks is the best response to a stagnating business: There may not be a short term prospect to be able to invest that cash pile in new product lines, for example.
But it's bad for you if you invest without understanding what is going on. Then again, that's always the case.