News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Should Bountysource allow committers to delist their proj... by maxerickson on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @11:47AM (#8590757)
The licensing is a sideshow.

If things get to the point where Bountysource is pointing at the terms of the license to defend what they are doing, it's pretty likely they are also at the point where they are significantly undermining the idea that what they are doing is helping the project.

Attaching the bounties to specific issues does seem less fraught than tipping every commit for a project.

It's a little discouraging that "claiming a bounty" only means you can use it on Bountysource, as the likely reason to do that is for promotion (it sounds a lot better to have a bunch of situations where you can say there is no fee and only one where there is a fee):

Does 100% of the bounty go to the developer?

The developer who solves the issue will receive the full bounty amount in their Bountysource account. These funds can be used to create more bounties, donate to teams, or pledge fundraisers. If a developer wishes to cash out their balance there will be a 10% fee.

What does it cost to claim a bounty?

Nothing. The amount displayed as the bounty total is the exact amount a developer will receive in their Bountysource account upon payout.

Just inverting the order of those makes it seem pretty silly:

What does it cost to claim a bounty?

Nothing. The amount displayed as the bounty total is the exact amount a developer will receive in their Bountysource account upon payout.

Does 100% of the bounty go to the developer?

The developer who solves the issue will receive the full bounty amount in their Bountysource account. These funds can be used to create more bounties, donate to teams, or pledge fundraisers. If a developer wishes to cash out their balance there will be a 10% fee.

Re:Should Bountysource allow committers to delist their proj... by jordigh on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @11:53AM (#8590792)
> The licensing is a sideshow.

No, it is fundamental to why bountysource can even possibly exist, as well as companies like Red Hat or Collabora. We built a system of free licenses since the late 80's that allow this kind of business. If you don't want to allow this sort of business, you need a different license. No Microsoft employee can possibly use bountysource to fund a project to improve Excel, not even if they wanted to. The license terms don't allow it.

> Just inverting the order of those makes it seem pretty silly:

I'm not sure I see the problem here. I suppose you object to the meaning of "claim" not being the same as "cash out"? That does seem a bit problematic.

Re:Should Bountysource allow committers to delist their proj... by maxerickson on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @11:58AM (#8590820)
Your reply about the license doesn't address the point I made in the next paragraph, that legalistic shenanigans probably aren't going to end up helping any project.

For "claim" vs "cash out", yes, I was thinking the distinction is rather artificial.

Re:Should Bountysource allow committers to delist their proj... by dllthomas on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @11:56AM (#8590805)
'It's a little discouraging that "claiming a bounty" only means you can use it on Bountysource'

They've got to take their cut at some point. I think forgoing it when the funds are re-used in the system is strictly a positive thing - yes, it benefits them, but it also benefits projects and developers. I don't disagree that the above could be phrased better, but I actually don't have strong objection to the existing language. The act that incurs the fee is withdrawing, not claiming.

Re:Should Bountysource allow committers to delist their proj... by maxerickson on Tuesday November 11, 2014 @04:58PM (#8592499)
I thought about this some, I don't think it is a big deal, and different language would probably fix most of it.

They could also make a more substantive change and include a fee in incoming payments. They know how much they take in and how much is cashed out, so the fee could still be benchmarked to ~10% of pay outs.

It's slightly harder to explain and it wouldn't ever be as round a number as 10%, but an advantage is that people setting up a bounty would then see how much would end up in developer hands and how much the fees are, prior to making the payment.