So you're saying that every time someone figures out a new way to program, they should throw away their tools and rebuild everything from scratch? No thanks.
The reason I stick with Perl is because I can use all the "bad code" that happens to work, and replace it as time permits (or as I need to maintain and extend it).
If you want to keep using Perl and enjoy the new stuff, that's great. For those who jumped ship and got up to speed on a new platform (as I did after 8 years of Perl), I don't see much reason to come back. Even Ruby's lacklustre performance is almost on a par with Perl now - http://shootout.alioth.debian.org/u32q/benchmark.php?test=al... - and Python is developing at a great pace.
I think Perl has better libraries, but learning those and discarding your experience with one of the other languages is probably not much of a net gain.
But why repeat that, since it is a standard answer in all these endless discussions?
Let me instead note one big advantage for Perl: There are much fewer embarrassing trolls doing language wars.
The thing is, it's like complaining that duct tape is poorly used.. which is often true, but duct tape still rules ;-) Perl has more than its fair share of problems but it has bound a lot of the Web together over the years. (Oh, and more recently there are some really clean, well structured Perl projects out there, but.. too little too late IMHO.)