I don't think this is true. I have a phone here I only use for development where I don't think I changed that setting and it's on.
First we figured out how to disable cellular data, since the phone with the minimum data plan gets only 100MB of usage per month, it's definitely too much to ask that one should police their applications and "just not use data" -- I don't have to tell you how easy it would be to accidentally go over this cap if you are actually using apps or any features of the iPhone at all, and the incidental metered usage rates are just absolutely ridiculous.
Then we had to go and find the Send as SMS setting, which was disabled by default, because text messaging to other iPhones only ever worked when she was in a WiFi zone. She would receive a flurry of messages she was missing while out, immediately when she got home, obviously a symptom of this issue with iMessage.
Even now, with the setting enabled, other iPhones won't reach her if they try to send a message when she's not in WiFi zones, because they still have this setting disabled. You have to show all your friends with iPhones how to enable this setting, or to force one message through individually, or just bite the bullet and pay for a real data plan. It does seem to be all by design, some type of collusion with the phone carrier(s) to make more money on data plans.
I once had Spotify eat my entire data for the month in a few hours because wifi was spotty and it just went on to stream (in max quality) over 3G.
Another issue, especially in Europe, is international roaming. When you're near a border, your device may be roaming in the neighboring countries network because their signal is stronger, so you really have to catch the "welcome to foo network" sms and turn off data roaming (or pay for an "EU Day Pack").
I haven't seen any articles that suggest you should disable iMessage unless you are dropping your iPhone completely. It was totally not obvious to me that you can even do this, and I am professional. ^_^ (I don't have my own iPhone, so I've never had to wrangle with these issues on my own.)
the problem that really exists with iMessage is that it's easy to enroll but people forget to unenroll when they move their number away from iPhone.
http://support.apple.com/en-us/TS2755
This was the experience of the person who initiated the class action suit:
"21. Apple personnel informed Plaintiff that even though she had turned iMessage off in her old iPhone she may still not be receiving all her text messages because some texters using Apple devices may not be using the latest Apple iOS version. Rather than Apple coming up with a solution to a problem created by Apple, Apple's representative instead suggested to Plaintiff that Plaintiff get her text message senders to update their Apple iOS to the latest version, or have them delete and then re-add Plaintiff as their contact, or have Plaintiff and these unsuccessful Apple texters start a new text conversation with Plaintiff."
http://www.slideshare.net/harrisonrweber/apple-imessage-laws...
So by default, it sends a secure end-to-end message, and you'd prefer it to fail back and send an insecure SMS logged by your telco? (Verizon, for example, makes your SMS history available in a web portal.)
I think the bigger issue would be if iMessage burned your SMS plan and sent insecure messages without you explicitly asking to.
Defaulting to losing the security and privacy seems more "frankly absolutely ridiculous".
I think a lot more users would be surprised that iMessage doesn't burn through your SMS plan than those would be surprised if it did.
The issue is that there is little information provided to the user to indicate why there is an issue, but it most certainly should fail closed.
Telcos being in the business of handling my conversations anyway and Apple being a hardware vendor from a different continent.
http://tidbits.com/resources/2013-10/iMessage-failure.png
(Unfortunately that didn't work for the issue fixed by this tool, since the iMessage never actually failed from the sender's perspective)
I've tried disabling iMessage on my iphone several times. I then have nothing connected to my iMessage account, but I still miss out on loads of messages from people who have the "Send by SMS" option disabled. Their devices are not told that I am no longer using iMessage.
I went to the apple store to ask about this, and I was told the only solution was to get all my contacts to ensure "Send by SMS" is turned on. Which is frankly absolutely ridiculous!