After all, content isn't "consumed" when watched, it's there forever (unless the BBC tape over the master).
I used to be a strong supporter of the BBC, but their news has been badly crippled by the Hutton report, BBC3 is a mess (not as bad as Channel 4), I'm not really interested in their drama, and their light entertainment is often cringeworthy.
However, the documentaries on BBC4 and especially the archive material are excellent. BBC radio is usually high quality too, when it's not suffering from random acts of management ( http://www.theguardian.com/media/2012/nov/01/axed-danny-bake... )
Or Comcast. Just listen to the endless complaints about the zillion channels paid for versus the few that get watched.
But the "not a good model" thing is ideological, not practical. It undeniably works in the sense of sustainably producing high-quality content, which is the point at issue here.