News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Computer Scientists Ask Supreme Court to Rule APIs Can’t ... by pbhjpbhj on Saturday November 08, 2014 @06:31PM (#8578522)
>* the concept of passing around file descriptors as small integers, etc, is definitely a creative expression, distinct from the underlying functionality* //

If you pass the file descriptors because that looks pretty, because of the beauty of the form and not for any functional effect. And, if the same functional effect (if there is one) can be achieved in other obvious and equally functional ways, so the only reason to do it this way is aesthetic, then yes - the essential elements are creative.

Just because you can achieve the same technical outcome in a different way doesn't make this way specifically creative however.

If an obvious way to create a specific technical effect creates a specific art-like outcome too then it's probably not copyrightable. Tyre treads, say: if your tread is created to appear different and there's no other reason to make it that way then you're covered by copyright; but if they have a technical benefit and you don't have other IP protection (patent or design patent) then others are free to duplicate that design because they are allowed to generate that technical outcome and the visual "artistry" is subordinate to that it's emergent rather than being directed.

There are no comments on this comment yet.