Re:Computer Scientists Ask Supreme Court to Rule APIs Can’t ...
by AnthonyMouse on Saturday November 08, 2014 @04:42PM
(#8578233)
> The real issue in this case is that a judge, applying the copyright law, simply does not care about whether finding API's to be copyrightable hinders interoperability or cloning of software. It's simply not legally relevant.
How is it not? Interoperability is functional. If you can't copyright function then you shouldn't be able to copyright anything necessary for interoperability.
> The lynchpin of copyright is originality and creativity. Are the Java API's original and creative? That's the only relevant question.
That obviously isn't the only question, otherwise you could copyright anything which is patentable and get 95 years of monopoly rather than 20.
How is it not? Interoperability is functional. If you can't copyright function then you shouldn't be able to copyright anything necessary for interoperability.
> The lynchpin of copyright is originality and creativity. Are the Java API's original and creative? That's the only relevant question.
That obviously isn't the only question, otherwise you could copyright anything which is patentable and get 95 years of monopoly rather than 20.