Re:Computer Scientists Ask Supreme Court to Rule APIs Can’t ...
by rayiner on Saturday November 08, 2014 @02:06PM
(#8577827)
> [A]nybody should be free to reimplement the same interfaces, no matter how creative my design. Anything else would destroy competition in the software industry and promote a virtual dystopia of vendor lock-in.
But that isn't a technical argument. If it had some empirical support it might be an economic one, but it's mostly just an ideological argument. One that, I might add, many software engineers would disagree with.
Re:Computer Scientists Ask Supreme Court to Rule APIs Can’t ...
by nitrogen on Sunday November 09, 2014 @04:00AM
(#8579445)
I'd like to meet one of these hypothetical "many software engineers" whose political opinions are so destructive to their own field.
Re:Computer Scientists Ask Supreme Court to Rule APIs Can’t ...
by rayiner on Sunday November 09, 2014 @09:06AM
(#8579915)
Not practicing anymore, but I had those political views while I was working as an engineer. I simply don't believe you have a blanket right to inter operate without the consent of the creator. I bet you'll find plenty in companies that actually create and sell software as their business model.
Re:Computer Scientists Ask Supreme Court to Rule APIs Can’t ...
by nitrogen on Monday November 10, 2014 @12:48AM
(#8582192)
I simply don't believe you have a blanket right to inter operate without the consent of the creator.
The courts have regarded interoperability as a fair use in the past. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sega_v._Accolade
That is exactly why a legal professional is the wrong person to decide the issue. I've written plenty of APIs myself, and when it comes to interoperability, anybody should be free to reimplement the same interfaces, no matter how creative my design. Anything else would destroy competition in the software industry and promote a virtual dystopia of vendor lock-in.