News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Computer Scientists Ask Supreme Court to Rule APIs Can’t ... by dragonwriter on Saturday November 08, 2014 @11:19AM (#8577276)
> Although these issues are very important, something feels wrong about having the Supreme Court justices (avg. age ~70) rule on tech matters like this.

Its not a tech matter, its a matter of the application of Copyright law. Its exactly what the Supreme Court exists to do.

> We need a new legal system for arbitrating disputes in technical disciplines overseen by a panel of technical experts.

Specialized trial or intermediate appellate courts of this type may make some sense (though such a specialized body --whose members are no doubt both drawn from and likely to leave to industry -- runs a particular risk of regulatory capture and becoming a body that reflects very well the interests of the bigger players in the industry), but I don't see any good reason for fragmentation at the top of the judicial branch just because technology, so I don't see any reason that ultimately such issues wouldn't end up with the Supreme Court.

> Or perhaps a trial by jury where the selection criteria is employment in the relevant discipline for at least 10 years (academia or corporate).

Specialized juries defeat the purpose of trial by jury -- and, anyway, then you just create a bunch of additional litigation over the boundaries of the "relevant discipline" for each case as each side tries to set the experience qualifications to suit the pool of jurors it thinks will be most favorable.

There are no comments on this comment yet.