As JCR wrote: "The safe and sane approach is to contact CERT [3,4] through their vulnerability reporting page [5] and let them contact the vendor."
[5] http://www.kb.cert.org/vuls/html/report-a-vulnerability/
All-in-all, don't tell people unless you have explicit, written proof of the companies consent to pentest their application because its simply not worth risking your entire life because someone in power's day is ruined by your curiosity.
Just keep your mouth shut or you will quite likely be sued. The only thing you should do is simply not just trust that particular company with your data anymore.
If the risk to public good is great enough and the bug simply must be revealed then it should be done anonymously and with full disclosure. Contacting the company will only give your address to them.
The OP said he used a form for reporting security vulnerabilities on the site. Does he still have to be afraid to get sued in such a case?
They are not a general 'help everyone' organization for people who get into technological legal trouble- the closest they come is having a list of law firms they refer uninteresting legal business to.
I'm still wondering if it has any legal influence in the US when a site provides a form for reporting vulnerabilities.
Also if you are sued for libel in US and prove that they indeed have a security hole that gives them the evidence directly to sue you for 'hacking' their site.
What?
http://www.senseaboutscience.org/data/files/A_quick_guide_to...
> Justification: a defendant must show that the substance and fact of what they have written is true. However, a judge decides what the words meant, and therefore what a defendant must prove to be true – sometimes not what a defendant expects.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/English_defamation_law
> Allowable defences are justification (i.e. the truth of the statement),
Edit:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Defamation_Act_2013
> and introducing new statutory defences of truth, honest opinion, and 'publication on a matter of public interest' or privileged publications (including peer reviewed scientific journals),
> The court ruled in the case of Noonan v. Staples that truth published with “actual malice” gleaned from the context of the statement can give rise to a libel lawsuit.
Does the company have a bug bounty policy?
No?
Then keep your mouth shut and get on with your life.
A significant percentage of people in power will react to unsolicited warnings of security vulnerabilities by attacking you as though you were their enemy. Worse, the law is at least not clearly on your side. This is not theoretical: people have come to significant harm in this way. Being a hero is great. Being a martyr? Not so much. You don't want next week's top HN story to be an appeal for donations to the legal defense fund of sah88.