News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Who ordered memory fences on an x86? (2008) by davidtgoldblatt on Friday November 07, 2014 @01:49PM (#8574023)
By the way, in case anyone was curious about the comment in the article:

> Since fences are so expensive, couldn’t you add a dummy assembly instruction that prevents the X86 from re-ordering? So the pseudo assembly for thread 0 might become:

    > store(zeroWants, 1)
    > store(victim, 0)
    > r0 = load(victim) ; NEW DUMMY INSTRUCTION
    > r0 = load(oneWants)
    > r1 = load(victim)
> Since the dummy instruction is a load, the X86 can’t reorder the other loads before it. Also, since it loads from “victim”, the X86 can’t move it before the store to “victim”.

> If you do this to both threads, does that solve the problem?

This doesn't work. Intel specifically calls out these sorts of attempts to get a fake memory barrier: "The memory-ordering model allows concurrent stores by two processors to be seen in different orders by those two processors; specifically, each processor may perceive its own store occurring before that of the other." This is true in practice as well as in theory.

A related trick that does work in practice (though it is also banned by Intel) is to write to the low-order bytes of a word, read the entire word, and get the high-order bytes. It's sort of a single-word StoreLoad barrier. There's a paper from Sun that documents it further: http://home.comcast.net/~pjbishop/Dave/QRL-OpLocks-BiasedLoc... .

There are no comments on this comment yet.