News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Computers Are Not Designed for Productivity by Animats on Friday November 07, 2014 @01:07PM (#8573777)
The author may be on to something with the line "A popup notification that runs without concern for what the user is doing is hostile behavior. Notice how there's no API in any OS for "is now a good time to interrupt the user?". Maybe there should be."

Notifications could be deferred while the user is actively typing. When the user goes idle, deferred notifications can be displayed. This becomes more important as more "push" features are crammed into browsers and apps.

Re:Computers Are Not Designed for Productivity by FreezerburnV on Friday November 07, 2014 @01:10PM (#8573797)
I'd like to point out that even if a user goes idle, it might still be a bad time to display notifications. What if a developer is working on a hard problem, and pauses for a while to think about the problem, maybe doodle on a whiteboard/paper, etc.? This could actually be the most damaging time to display a distraction to the developer. The solution to this kind of problem would likely need to be slightly different, possibly including simple mechanics such as "Don't bother me during x time" or "Don't bother me for an hour" to give someone that time they need to just focus/think about something for a block of time.
Re:Computers Are Not Designed for Productivity by ajuc on Friday November 07, 2014 @01:22PM (#8573869)
There are already problems with the assumption (user idle=nothing important happens).

Namely I'm trying to watch a movie and screen goes black after 30 minutes (yes I know how to configure this, just an example).

Re:Computers Are Not Designed for Productivity by sp332 on Friday November 07, 2014 @02:26PM (#8574192)
That's an interesting example, because there is an API for movie-playing programs to disable the screensaver while they're playing.
Re:Computers Are Not Designed for Productivity by goblin89 on Friday November 07, 2014 @05:25PM (#8574986)
> A popup notification that runs without concern for what the user is doing is hostile behavior. Notice how there's no API in any OS for "is now a good time to interrupt the user?". Maybe there should be.

This isn’t correct, actually. There is the Do Not Disturb mode in OS X that disables any non-essential notifications and alerts. It can be toggled manually for one day, or according to user-set daily start and end times.

Of course, even though the API exists, apps use it differently and somewhat inconsistently: for example, Apple’s native FaceTime will not distract you in DND mode, but Skype will if someone calls you.

Point being, there is an example of such API that tells any app that asks whether is now a good time to interrupt the user. (Not to argue that actually inferring what you do and avoiding distracting and stealing focus in the middle of typing, as in your example, would take it to another level.)

Re:Computers Are Not Designed for Productivity by dllthomas on Sunday November 09, 2014 @04:20PM (#8580937)
I've been wanting to put together a notification daemon that lets me batch notifications based on priority (and also review a history of recent notifications).
Re:Computers Are Not Designed for Productivity by denova on Friday November 07, 2014 @01:40PM (#8573979)
In Gnome 3 there's a nice notifications on/off button in the notifications tray. I like manual controls.
Re:Computers Are Not Designed for Productivity by Dewie on Friday November 07, 2014 @02:04PM (#8574093)
Windows 8.0 seems to have become especially bad when it comes to this. All of a sudden it will pop up and focus a (modal) window - all there is is the wallpaper (fuzzied) and the window, where did my application go?

No Windows, I don't want to update Java (yet again) when I'm playing a fullscreened video game.

Re:Computers Are Not Designed for Productivity by mcdougle on Friday November 07, 2014 @02:11PM (#8574116)
And then the full-screen application crashes because it was designed for Windows 7