News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Geeks Try Google Wave, Have Mixed Feelings by swombat on Friday October 02, 2009 @08:44AM (#856890)
It's slick to be sure. However, what I keep asking myself is this: what problem does it solve?

If it's not obvious to you what problem it solves, then you've spent too long away from corporate environments with their massive, unwieldy threads of emails flying about, full mailboxes, and other email issues.

The problem that Wave solves is blindingly obvious to anyone who uses email as a primary tool to work with teams. Whether it's the right solution is another question altogether, but the problem is definitely there.

Re:Geeks Try Google Wave, Have Mixed Feelings by mrshoe on Friday October 02, 2009 @11:16AM (#857197)
The problem is definitely there, but, after using wave for a couple of months now, I don't think it's the right solution.

I would echo a lot of other reviews: it's too complex and ambitious. This applies to the protocol/platform as well as their initial client. There's just so much going on and it's trying to do so much at once that it's very unwieldy.

I think simplicity is an important feature if you want new software to gain traction, and especially if you want new protocols to be adopted. I think simpler tools like http://shoptalkapp.com (disclosure: co-founder) do a better job of solving the problem you describe. And the tools we use to build it, which are gradually being open sourced at http://dieselweb.org, make real-time web apps pretty accessible to developers.

Having used the wave client and read about the protocol, I just think both are too complex to really gain traction. All the bugs in Gooogle's own wave client are evidence that it's not an easy platform to write apps on, at least at this point. I'm sure they'll continue to pour tons of resources into it, and maybe they'll turn it around. Time will tell.

Re:Geeks Try Google Wave, Have Mixed Feelings by axod on Friday October 02, 2009 @09:39AM (#856980)
If that's the case I think they should narrow and focus. If it's a tool for corporates to communicate, 'mailing lists 2.0?' then it'd be cool to go that way.

Being marketed as "It can do everything!!! It's the new internet!", which seems to be the current strategy, could pay off, but maybe not. Likely only with geeks wanting to play with technology.

I'd be really surprised if it takes off with consumers quite yet.

Re:Geeks Try Google Wave, Have Mixed Feelings by m0digital on Saturday October 03, 2009 @12:41AM (#858523)
"Mailing lists 2.0" is an interesting term. It's kind of the principle we have used in building MooGroups http://moogroups.com. Instead of setting up a mailing list only for a specific group of people you email often, we make it so that essentially each group email is its own mailing list, so people who are part of that group email can email each other in an organized fashion or opt-out as needed.

Unlike Google Wave, MooGroups is available now, being improved upon everyday, doesn't require any signup, and allows you to use any email system.

Re:Geeks Try Google Wave, Have Mixed Feelings by roc on Friday October 02, 2009 @10:50AM (#857118)
It's not just a tool for corporates though; they're just a handy example because at their scale the problems are unavoidable.

If you have to coordinate communication and collaboration among any group of people, Wave will help. Though if it's only 2, 5 or 10 people, it's more likely you can get everyone to agree on convention and get by with older tools.

Re:Geeks Try Google Wave, Have Mixed Feelings by elblanco on Friday October 02, 2009 @10:43AM (#857097)
It definitely is over-hyped. I think it has to do with the focus seemingly on the developer addons and bots and such vs. the collaborative communication medium.

Perhaps they thought they had to differentiate from message boards or IM or email or IRC?

Re:Geeks Try Google Wave, Have Mixed Feelings by sp332 on Friday October 02, 2009 @09:59AM (#857010)
They need to get buy-in from geeks first, otherwise no one will write programs for it.
Re:Geeks Try Google Wave, Have Mixed Feelings by isamuel on Friday October 02, 2009 @10:29AM (#857071)
This is probably true. But if the purpose of Wave is to be "Collaboration Tool for Large Corporations to Share TPS Reports," isn't it doomed with most hackers anyway? Who would want to write programs for that?
Re:Geeks Try Google Wave, Have Mixed Feelings by axod on Friday October 02, 2009 @05:16PM (#858058)
...and in XML :/ eugh
Re:Geeks Try Google Wave, Have Mixed Feelings by elblanco on Friday October 02, 2009 @10:42AM (#857093)
Agreed, I get around 100-200 emails a day. Most of them are just continuations of a single conversation between the same 2-3 people. On top of that, because email can get unwieldy, we often just fall back on IM for many things.

Wave seems almost obvious except that it wasn't invented earlier.

Re:Geeks Try Google Wave, Have Mixed Feelings by thismat on Friday October 02, 2009 @09:20AM (#856948)
It doesn't really solve this problem when corporations don't want to trust their data to google. It's well known that gmail doesn't comply with HIPAA/SOX and doesn't offer any kind of guarantee on data when corporations use it, this is a huge issue for adoption in the workplace by many corporations.

I could be missing something though, is Wave something you can install locally and have control over? It's not Google's style so I'd guess not.

If I'm mistaken, I'm more than willing to be enlightened.

Re:Geeks Try Google Wave, Have Mixed Feelings by tumult on Friday October 02, 2009 @09:31AM (#856966)
Yes, it's an open protocol. http://www.waveprotocol.org/ It's still being revised and edited. There are example clients and servers based on the actual code Google is using. It would have taken you about 5 seconds to search for this, btw. :]
Re:Geeks Try Google Wave, Have Mixed Feelings by thismat on Friday October 02, 2009 @09:40AM (#856981)
Indeed, I could have searched and dug around for it, but work is calling and I wanted to get in as much hackernews as possible before starting the day. Thank you for the link, will be reading up on it later as it looks very interesting.
Re:Geeks Try Google Wave, Have Mixed Feelings by mbrubeck on Friday October 02, 2009 @11:12AM (#857192)
Not only that, but it's a federated protocol (like email), so your company can set up its own Wave server, and you can communicate through it with users on any server.
Re:Geeks Try Google Wave, Have Mixed Feelings by tumult on Friday October 02, 2009 @11:31AM (#857245)
It is, but federation doesn't work yet. They're saying they're aiming for the end of this month for working federation on the sandbox, which I eagerly await :]
Re:Geeks Try Google Wave, Have Mixed Feelings by tybris on Friday October 02, 2009 @11:21AM (#857213)
If I don't want to wait I use jabber. If I DO want to wait I use e-mail.
Re:Geeks Try Google Wave, Have Mixed Feelings by akrymski on Friday October 02, 2009 @11:30AM (#857238)
I think CampFire solves most of these problems much more elegantly.
Re:Geeks Try Google Wave, Have Mixed Feelings by kburn on Friday October 02, 2009 @05:09PM (#858043)
I'm not familiar with Campfire. How well does it scale teamwise?
Re:Geeks Try Google Wave, Have Mixed Feelings by akrymski on Monday October 05, 2009 @08:04AM (#861613)
It's effectively group chat. I believe 37 signals themselves use it. Scales well to most situations, where you have groups of under 20 people working on any one project at a time.