Re:Duke Engines' compact, lightweight valveless axial engine
by noir_lord on Thursday November 06, 2014 @12:28PM
(#8568255)
In this context it is irrelevant since my comparison was purely one of power output against displacement.
The Turbo allows a given displacement to output more power for a given displacement, indeed volvo have 2 litre putting out 450hp (uses staged turbo's one of which is electrically driven), I wasnt comparing the nearest ICE equivalent to the rotary.
I don't have time to do more thorough research right now, but the Ford Duratec 30 series of engines [1] is roughly comparable in both displacement and cylinder count and produces between 200 and 240 HP depending on configuration which puts this engine slightly ahead of normal engines from a performance perspective (smaller form factor and lighter).
Is there any apples to apples comparison that you can find that actually makes this development look substantially inferior? I get that you used a diesel because historically that gave the ICE an advantage but with modern diesel technology and forced induction they aren't the same animal.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ford_Duratec_V6_engine#3.0_L
Edit: changed 'pre-combustion' to 'pre-compression' for clarity on volumetric efficiency definition.