Re:Former NSA lawyer: the cyberwar is between tech firms and...
by maxerickson on Wednesday November 05, 2014 @10:12AM
(#8562095)
The self-incrimination clause in the U.S. Constitution is rooted more in preventing the government from using coercion than it is in concern over the veracity of any testimony obtained through that coercion (of course torturing people into confessing crimes they did not commit is a major historical motivation for the provision, but mechanistically, it is not concerned with truth).
When it comes to a locked safe, the U.S. Supreme court still muses about whether revealing the combination to a lock is testimonial. For instance:
http://blogs.denverpost.com/crime/2012/01/05/why-criminals-s...
http://illinoisjltp.com/timelytech/is-the-battle-over-for-sm...
WRT decryption the USA is currently in a weird spot: some countries don't have the same hangups about forcing people to reveal encryption keys or unlock codes if there is a valid warrant or court order. I think the USA will go the same direction; if I understand American history correctly the purpose of the 5th Amendment was to avoid people being coerced into giving false testimony? It doesn't really apply to things like combination locks or passwords where there's no coercion risk so the original reasoning behind the amendment would not apply.
My white collar example was thinking about banks, anti-trust and other such things where the suspect is the organisation as a whole.