News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OpenBSD drops loadable kernel module support by ChuckMcM on Monday November 03, 2014 @07:51PM (#8554590)

   > Are they going to build all the supported HW device 
   > drivers all into the kernel image?
Historically that was what the 'Generic' kernel was, something which would boot on any system. A typical system configuration would be to boot the generic kernel, edit the configuration file to select only those devices and features that were going to be used, config and then make that kernel. Then boot from the configured kernel from then on.

There has been both a lot of research and debate about various 'microkernel' strategies where the core of the micro-kernel really only knows how to access the boot disk and load modules. Then as hardware is probed and discovered, modules to support that hardware is loaded.

As a desktop machine kernel, micro-kernels allow for changes in the hardware configuration to occur fairly easily without a lot of user visible fuss. But they do leave open the vulnerability that the module system can be exploited. Server systems generally change less frequently and hardware changes beyond adding or removing a disk drive are often quite rare.

Things are always trade-offs.

I wonder if there is anyone doing mixed virtualization studies. Using a hypervisor that is locked down for the lower layer and then booting the "user" machine for interactive use. This is a very powerful architectural choice and was been used for decades in IBM's mainframe OS. Perhaps we'll see a consumer OS based on those principles at some point.

Re:OpenBSD drops loadable kernel module support by imanaccount247 on Tuesday November 04, 2014 @04:30AM (#8555715)
Modules have nothing to do with microkernels. A system like you are describing is still a monolithic kernel. It changes nothing about the behavior of the system, it just saves a couple of MB of RAM. A microkernel runs the drivers as separate userspace programs, there are no modules involved.