News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:IT Concepts That Non-IT People Don’t Get by zck on Wednesday September 30, 2009 @12:49PM (#852955)
>8. What Memory (RAM) Is For

The best analogy I can find for RAM is short-term memory. RAM holds less stuff than long-term memory (hard disk), but is faster to access. And if you don't put an item into long-term memory (write to disk), you forget it (when the power is turned off). People seem to understand that.

Re:IT Concepts That Non-IT People Don’t Get by rufo on Wednesday September 30, 2009 @01:34PM (#853104)
I tend to liken RAM to a table, programs/data to books, and the hard drive to a bookshelf.

You can't read stuff on a bookshelf; you have to take it out and put it on the table to open it. (Sure, you can read a book on a couch, but this is the computer we're talking about - it has certain rules.)

You can take out as many books from the bookshelf as you like, as long as they fit on the open table.

If you run out of table space, you need to make more space on the table, and the only way to do that is to put books back on the shelf.

If you're trying to open too many books at once with too little table space, the only thing you can do is constantly go back and forth between the bookshelf and the table, open the book, find your place, etc., read a word, take it back, open the previous book, write it down, etc., and it's going to take you way longer to do the same work.

Re:IT Concepts That Non-IT People Don’t Get by Periodic on Wednesday September 30, 2009 @02:46PM (#853317)
That's a great analogy. I like it. I've been using the short-term memory analogy, but this fits a lot better. I know that we don't entirely understand our brain, but everyone understands books and a table.

Too bad memory is divided into "pages" and not "books".

Re:IT Concepts That Non-IT People Don’t Get by jimbokun on Wednesday September 30, 2009 @05:50PM (#853805)
Or, equivalently, the table/bookshelf is a great analogy for short and long term memory. :)
Re:IT Concepts That Non-IT People Don’t Get by chops on Wednesday September 30, 2009 @05:35PM (#853763)
A good one indeed. I use a similar one:

RAM is your desktop (literal desktop, as in the "top of your desk"). The more desk space you have, the more "things" you can be working on at the same time.

Disk Space is the file cabinet. Shutting down is like cleaning your desk, whatever doesn't get put back into the file cabinet gets thrown away.

Re:IT Concepts That Non-IT People Don’t Get by theBobMcCormick on Wednesday September 30, 2009 @03:32PM (#853445)
I use that analogy also. It really helps users to understand how memory and hard drive space are two different things.

I can't tell you how many times I've had users tell me that they got some variety of out of memory error, then immediately start describing how they tried to delete stuff from their hard drive to fix it. :-)

Re:IT Concepts That Non-IT People Don’t Get by PebblesRox on Wednesday September 30, 2009 @05:03PM (#853681)
And if you need to, you can decide to buy a bigger table!
Re:IT Concepts That Non-IT People Don’t Get by drusenko on Wednesday September 30, 2009 @02:10PM (#853222)
Was just about to post this same comment. RAM is like telling someone to remember a 7 digit number -- they could probably repeat it to you right away, but remembering it in an hour, or a day, is a lot harder.
Re:IT Concepts That Non-IT People Don’t Get by hernan7 on Wednesday September 30, 2009 @05:24PM (#853744)
Good analogy. A computer with not enough RAM would be like Dory from Finding Nemo.
Re:IT Concepts That Non-IT People Don’t Get by mdg on Wednesday September 30, 2009 @04:27PM (#853587)
Related to #8 but not directly to what you said:

> Making the problem worse is that fact that most consumer PCs are sold with the bare minimum of RAM.

Is this true still? I thought it was clever marketing to sell your laptop with 4 gigs and a 32 bit OS. Not only can the OS not address all that RAM, but it wont use all of it. To the uninformed consumer, which this article is about, they think 'Wow! 4 gigs?! This other one only has (n, where n < 4) gigs, so this 4 gig computer must be a better deal!"