News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Experiment: Paying for performance works (for teachers in... by yummyfajitas on Wednesday September 30, 2009 @12:28PM (#852864)
They also accounted for it by studying performance on science and social studies tests. Both improved. However, it would be useful to follow up with a differently structured test to see how much comes from test prep.

Incidentally, bringing up the SAT is a red herring. The SAT was originally meant to measure g/intelligence/"aptitude". It did this by measuring a body of knowledge which is not explicitly taught in school, giving questions like wheel : car -> pick one of [leg: horse, egg : chicken, computer : TV]. Obviously, you can improve performance by explicitly teaching that knowledge (e.g., memorizing analogies).

A subject test does not suffer from this problem, since it is designed to measure subject knowledge rather than aptitude. You can improve performance on a multiplication test by memorizing multiplication tables, but so what? Multiplication performance is what you are trying to measure, it's not a proxy for something else.

There are no comments on this comment yet.