My engineering and computer science classes taught me more about "how to think" than the liberal arts classes I took - those seemed to focus on regurgitating facts or the professor's viewpoint. And I certainly didn't get the impression that the in-major kids were doing anything different, just better practiced regurgitation.
I think if "liberal arts" education were fulfilling its promise, it would have long ago adopted programming (an unforgiving applied logic) as a core component (scheme/haskell, not python). People in general learn by example, while teachers (having already learned) tend to emphasize abstract models. This is a great recipe for model precession, fostering an illusion of thinking critically while being at the mercy of now-invisible built in assumptions.
I'm guessing your logic classes had similar problem solving where errors were objectively called out. I regrettably didn't take philosophy classes, but only softer things that were subjectively graded via essay. In retrospect, they seem like fine topics to have studied after one developed critical thinking skills, but when presented as competitors to hard logic they devolved into a subjective/memorization fest
(I'd love to upvote you for friendly insightful discussion, but I appear to be unable to vote on comments. email to hn@ has so far gone unanswered)
I.e. with engineering, reality is the check on the validity of your critical thinking. With liberal arts, there is no such check.
It's not hard to imagine going to a liberal arts college where the professors are all moderately to aggressively liberal and/or Democrat.
I'm not saying that it's RIGHT that this could happen, but that it's not unreasonable to expect that it COULD happen.
I don't know if that's because internet commenters in general just use the preceding comment as a springboard to jump onto their own soapbox, or if HN users are particularly bad at reading and responding to the content of a text (while loudly denouncing such worthless literary skills).
Is this really a good thing? There are certainly plenty of things in this world that are relative, unanswerable, or heuristics based on differing utility functions. But arguments about those things should still be logically right, based on differing assumptions that are made explicit.
Even then, there's the foggy feeling that remains, every thought exists in some context with some assumptions. You can continue to question what assumptions exist that you aren't aware of, and redefine your opinions through that vocabulary instead, and perhaps convince yourself into a point of view you would never consciously switch to given knowledge of the prior, through the trickery of time and language.
Trying to maintain a coherent view of the world assuming the possibility of relativism across all domains is insanity. Trying to function with that mass of unanswerables leading to possibly infinitely descending chains of undefined, fuzzy variables is like hitting a wall of meaningless symbols. It makes doing things in reality trivial. The task of coming to know what you explicitly, continuously define as unknowable is impossible.
In theory, logic is beautiful. But there's stuff that makes logic seem incomplete, when it comes to application. At the trail end of the thought, it still feels like thinking about everything all at once, while knowing nothing.
As opposed to, say, arguing about who is a better President - Obama or Bush? Liberal arts majors can argue that all day, and never be able to demonstrate a thing to be true.
Note that there have been many scientific theories that were debated persuasively, reasonably, and logically, until someone applied the scientific method and proved one side correct and the other false.
The entire world isn't engineering, and there are plenty of things that we have to agree to disagree on (we can come up with objective solutions that minimize the disagreement, but that only goes so far). Since softer subjects will always lack clear objective answers, we could hope for a change in liberal arts teaching that required creating independent rational arguments rather than getting by by restating the specific one the professor happens to believe in.
Consider:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Critical_thinking
It doesn't even mention the scientific method!
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scientific_method
The revolution in the human condition has been brought about by application of the scientific method - it's the most useful critical thinking skill ever devised.
Computer science varied depending on language - when it was Haskell the focus on thinking was a lot higher than when using Java or C, for me. The classes that used imperative languages tended to focus a lot more on nuts and bolts. Maybe that's just a preference of my uni though - they tended to teach algorithm classes etc in Haskell and database style classes in some imperative language, I think, so maybe the difference there is due to a choice from their side.
Organic chemistry, statistics, formal logic didnt evolve my thinking at all in my view.
I guess in short - the things that have developed my thinking the most are things that are about models and algorithms. You could probably run classes focusing on those, but Im not sure there is a big value in doing so compared to just teaching the subjects that are heavy in doing those tasks.
We don't need more critical thinkers we need constructive thinkers. People who add something new rather than learning what we already know.
You don't become good at critical thinking by studying critical thinking. The very problem with this approach is that you are in fact just learning a specific way of thinking and thus leaving out the critical part of it.
Furthermore in my experience many more technical people are actually great creative thinkers but not many liberal arts people are great technical thinkers.
You had bad professors and/or were skating through. To a degree, you will get out what you put in.
Perhaps in STEM fields good work product often is more defined (e.g., the number either is right or wrong) and therefore more efficient for professors to evaluate than in, for example, a history class where you analyze the primary documentary sources for and the causes of the Meiji Restoration.
The difference between Minerva and this is that at Minerva, it seems like the focus is directly teaching those things, whereas at a liberal arts college you learn those things very indirectly and usually filtered through existing disciplines. My brother is a biochem major at a liberal arts college and all that means is that he has to do more presentations than he would have had he gone to the state research university I did.
This is actually a dramatic shift from teaching concepts like analytical thinking, organization, communication, etc., indirectly via things like classics, philosophy, and other mostly-obsolete and practically useless things that are used as signalling for high wealth (ability to take classes that don't relate to a profession) and conscientiousness (ability to read a lot and write about it).
That said, the "critical thinking" in liberal arts is a joke. What actually happens is that the professor presents several arguments for or against a topic, and you regurgitate this on a paper.
As for whether learning critical thinking in the liberal arts is a direct or indirect result, I like this quote from Reed College's dean of the faculty Peter Steinberger:
"There’s only one thing that I think I can do, only one thing I’m qualified to do, and that’s help students learn how to think, to analyze, to develop intellectual discipline, to acquire a degree of mastery over one or another conceptual apparatus that helps us organize experience in compelling and defensible ways." [1]
He is not alone among teachers of the liberal arts in believing that while they are compelled by their individual disciplines, they are ultimately teaching students to think.
1. http://www.reed.edu/reed_magazine/sallyportal/posts/2014/an-...
I don't disagree that liberal arts colleges say the things you claim, I just dispute that they do them. One is much harder than the other.
"Deep Springs is founded on three principles, commonly called the "three pillars": academics, labor, and self-government."
Any other tidbits?
> Instead of "learning to think" and being prepared for a fictional career in academia
This is overstated. I expect that the great majority of high-paying jobs are held by people with liberal arts degrees. The idea that they are worthless in the job market is a popular exaggeration, but wrong.
> part of liberal arts education, especially at the most liberal artsy institutions (University of Chicago, Swarthmore, Reed, etc) is specifically training you the tools of an academic discipline
Having no expertise in this area myself ... I agree that learning how to be a professional academic is not widely valuable. However,
I suspect there is value in focusing on an academic discipline. The thinking required for academic disciplines -- especially in regard to creating new knowledge -- may differ from more practical ones, and learning something in depth differs from learning in more superficial breadth.
It may not matter so much what you learn, as long as you study something in depth.
Finally, it may prepare you well for graduate school, which is much more common than academic careers.
That said, according to the article there is one interesting innovation here. While traditional liberal arts schools value critical thinking over tangible skills, students still pick a major and working on a major within an academic department usually means being prepared for graduate school in that discipline. Instead this school tasks its students with creating something novel within their concentration, which is potentially a great way to compromise between the lofty ideals of a liberal arts education and the non-existent job market for academics. Instead of "learning to think" and being prepared for a fictional career in academia, you can learn to think and try to apply those critical thinking skills toward making a tangible impact on the world.