At this point, the parties have devolved to mirror the culture wars that have beset this country since its founding: urban vs. rural. There's money on both sides - agriculture and mineral wealth in rural areas, and finance/industrial wealth in urban areas, so it's not a rich vs. poor thing. It's almost purely a sociological divide along relative geographic lines at this point.
I can tell you I'm personally a suburban, technical person who votes Republican and it really isn't based upon social values.
Just look at all the GOP talking heads saying we need more restrictions on travel from Africa, we need to restrict the definition of marriage, we need to prevent abortion, we can't cut military spending, we need a huge border patrol, etc. The GOP beats the drum of small government, but are the first to enact big government when it suits their needs. See the Department of Homeland Security, enacted by a republican president with a republican congress, and which has in 12 years grown to become one of the biggest and most wasteful government agencies out there.
Politicians lie. It's their job. So we can't judge them based on what they say, we have to judge them based on what they do. And right now, unfortunately, an individual politician doesn't have the ability to contradict his party if he wants to keep his job. So we have to look at the party's track record, and when we do, it's pretty obvious that there's no choice for "relatively less government control". Both parties want more government control; just that the democrats want it in the form of government bureaucracy that creates dependency on the system, and the republicans want to dictate what people can and cannot do, then enforce it with an increasingly militarized police force.
The choice here is not between good and bad. It is between two less than optimal choices (which is most often the case in life).
Let me guess: You're a white heterosexual cisgendered man.
While gerrymandering does help explain the GOP's outsized representation in the House relative to their national vote share, the increasing dominance of the Democratic vote in large cities is probably more significant[1]. Essentially, if you wanted GOP representation in the House to mirror their national vote share, you'd be forced to draw some pretty nonsensical districts that sliced up urban centers so they could be mixed with the outlying (and sometimes way outlying) suburbs. Getting 90%+ of the vote in ward after ward of Chicago doesn't help your guy in Deerfield when he loses by 2%.
[1] http://mobile.nytimes.com/2014/09/07/upshot/why-democrats-ca...