Re:Scientists Decry "Flawed" and "Horrifying" Nationality Tests
by araneae on Wednesday September 30, 2009 @08:40AM
(#852284)
I think the wording is a bit strong- it's really not that horrifying- but it's certainly not scientifically sound. It's not like there's a mountain range surrounding Somalia that has prevented them from interbreeding with individuals from other countries for the last hundred thousand years. Heck, the place didn't really even exist until the 1950s.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Scientists Decry "Flawed" and "Horrifying" Nationality Tests
by electromagnetic on Wednesday September 30, 2009 @08:54AM
(#852305)
Well it is horrifying, they're planning on refusing people who are immigrating on humanitarian and compassionate grounds (refugee) based on their DNA.
Warfare doesn't check your DNA before it kills your spouse and children. Apparently Britain, however, checks your DNA before it decides to save you or not.
Re:Scientists Decry "Flawed" and "Horrifying" Nationality Tests
by araneae on Wednesday September 30, 2009 @11:53AM
(#852695)
So you believe in no immigration restrictions at all then? I think it's perfectly fair to only admit people into a country if they desperately need it. They just want a way to identify those people. This is the wrong way to do it, but that's a separate issue.
Re:Scientists Decry "Flawed" and "Horrifying" Nationality Tests
by hughprime on Wednesday September 30, 2009 @11:37AM
(#852637)
True, but the real villains here are the non-refugee immigrants who lie about their country of origin in order to get refugee status.
Re:Scientists Decry "Flawed" and "Horrifying" Nationality Tests
by biohacker42 on Wednesday September 30, 2009 @10:36AM
(#852479)
It's also horrifying because of how the government is using utterly misguided "science". It's like if they demanded everyone get homeopathic therapy.
Re:Scientists Decry "Flawed" and "Horrifying" Nationality Tests
by hughprime on Wednesday September 30, 2009 @11:45AM
(#852662)
It's not quite as bad as homeopathy. DNA evidence is worth something in these cases, but it's not conclusive -- the main problem is that government bureaucrats are too dumb to understand this and would treat it as conclusive.
If we knew the number of Somali citizens with "non-Somali" DNA and the number of non-Somali citizens with "Somali" DNA, then... well, there's another application for Bayesian statistics, I guess.