Cats happened about the same time agriculture did. They were attracted to the rodents, and less rodents meant we were happier - and they were happier with a reliable food source. At the beginning it might have helped to not be afraid of humans, but we probably didn't mess with them too much because they were helping us out with all the mice in our grains.
So the difference in behavior is clear, not just from a social species standpoint, but from the domestication path:
The European Wolf was domesticated to dogs as a hunting partner; the African Wildcat was domesticated to kill the rodents that devoured our foodstuffs. For the few few thousand years that was probably enough - they didn't have to make friends with us, just keep our food safe.
Earliest cat domestication evidence is 9,500 years old; earliest dog domestication evidence is about 36,000 years old.
They've still got quite a ways to go ;) Now if we could just start breeding them for social/intelligence instead of how weird and fluffy we can make them. Hard to morally advocate for breeding when the shelter/feral population is so damn high, though. (I feel the same way about dogs, though, tbh).
Increase of reproductive success is not an evolutionary pressure and is irrelevant in the context of the comment I was replying to.
And increase of reproductive success of a very similar population puts all kinds of evolutionary pressure on the less-advantaged population, as they compete for the same things. But more to the point, regardless of the exact words that your parent poster used, they clearly did not mean a very narrow definition of evolutionary pressure.
You should check your detector.
That sounds like lamarckism. Or do you suggest that cats were selectively bred for their social behaviour? I find it dubious.