Your other point has been addressed above; people don't know what they want. Asking them what they want their "ideal match" to answer is as foolhardy as asking them to describe their "ideal mate" neuron by neuron.
People do not, in fact, know what they want. But they can make educated guesses.
How does one go about making an EDUCATED guess with NO knowledge?
To put it plainly - statistical information assimilated from meaningless data is also meaningless. I don't know what my perfect mate looks like - and no one does. If you accept that premise, you are then forced to accept that any data gathered from some person A about what their perfect mate P is like is MEANINGLESS. So statistical algorithms from any such information yield meaningless data as well; ergo okcupid cannot do what it hopes to do. QED
While I agree that one's guess at a perfect partner might not be 100% accurate, are you sure you have no information on this at all? Here are some OkCupid questions. Would you be equally willing to date someone regardless of how they answered these questions?
-Is homosexuality a sin?
-How important is religion/God in your life?
-Are you happy with your life?
-Is interracial marriage a bad idea?
And I am certain I am not unique. Indeed, half of the enjoyment in getting to know someone is in the mutual effort expended in trying to understand how the other person was formed: thoughts, feelings, desires, etc - and this enjoyment is independent of the actual thoughts, feelings, etc themselves.
As relationships grow, both parties discover the thoughts, feelings, desires, etc. that were perhaps, formed irrationally - and then adjust accordingly. This is called personal discovery - and is evidence enough that most people are too inconsistent and too nearsighted for an approach such as the one okcupid employs.
That said - I wish them the best of luck.
In practice, the user base for OkCupid will change. And old users will reanswer questions sometimes too.
"Assuming you are even GETTING like thinkers, (which is tenuous at best) where is it written that like thinkers make great companions?"
That's not how it works. It's not as simple as "answer match questions and we hook you up with people who answered the same way". You can specify which answers your ideal match would give, even if those answers conflict with the answers you yourself give.
"most human beings make judgments based on appearances"
Which is why you upload photos to OkCupid instead of just using match percentages.