News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Veteran fraud expert sets his sights on Bitcoin by eternauta3k on Sunday October 26, 2014 @08:50PM (#8513219)
Won't increasing reliance on the blockchain lead to a wasteful computing power arms race?
Re:Veteran fraud expert sets his sights on Bitcoin by TomGullen on Sunday October 26, 2014 @09:07PM (#8513262)
Honestly, even if you consider it wasteful (and there's a strong argument to contest this) it's currently pretty low on the things to lose sleep over. There's a lot more low hanging fruit in wasted resources in this world that we should be looking at first. In my opinion Bitcoin comes under too much unfair scrutiny in this regard.
Re:Veteran fraud expert sets his sights on Bitcoin by eternauta3k on Sunday October 26, 2014 @09:29PM (#8513323)
Would that still be the case if a significant part of transactions went through Bitcoin?
Re:Veteran fraud expert sets his sights on Bitcoin by ougawouga on Sunday October 26, 2014 @09:57PM (#8513393)
Yes. The majority of the energy is spent maintaining the network's security. Once that security has been obtained, additional transaction volume -- assuming it's within the network's constraints -- will add little to no additional cost.

To expand, Bitcoin's security is maintained by the miners, who also expend the majority of the network's energy. Transaction volume for the most part is borne by all the network's full nodes, which use relatively little energy.

Re:Veteran fraud expert sets his sights on Bitcoin by DennisP on Sunday October 26, 2014 @10:20PM (#8513458)
Miners don't choose whether to mine based on whether the network is secure. They mine if it will be profitable to mine.

So we can expect the total cost of mining to be approximately equal to the total block rewards plus transaction fees. The more valuable Bitcoin becomes, the more valuable those rewards will be, and the more money will be spent on mining.

Some percentage of the mining cost will go to energy, and the rest to hardware. So it's possible to estimate the energy cost of mining at various price levels and times (since block rewards decrease over time).

Ignoring transaction fees, it's actually not terrible. I figured out a while back that it would be something like several gigawatts, if Bitcoin became a trillion-dollar currency in twenty years. But if transaction fees become significant it could get a lot worse. (Luckily there's some work in progress that could increase scalability enough to keep the fees low.)

Re:Veteran fraud expert sets his sights on Bitcoin by TomGullen on Sunday October 26, 2014 @09:32PM (#8513331)
I'm not sure, you'd have to measure the cost of Bitcoin computers versus costs of the parts of the current system of transaction that it replaced.

It would be difficult to measure!

Re:Veteran fraud expert sets his sights on Bitcoin by Estragon on Tuesday October 28, 2014 @01:32AM (#8519674)
This is one reason why burst coin is so interesting. It's mining algorithm uses stored pre computed values to force commitment of storage space rather than computation. It's way more efficient.
Re:Veteran fraud expert sets his sights on Bitcoin by weavejester on Sunday October 26, 2014 @09:52PM (#8513374)
Well, you don't necessarily need to build a blockchain on proof of work, and you don't necessarily need to use a proof of work algorithm that's easy to parallelise.