News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by AlexMuir on Sunday October 26, 2014 @06:39PM (#8512785)
Just so I'm clear is the current narrative that Uber, a multi-billion dollar private enterprise seeking to maximize its returns to a handful of shareholders, is single-handedly battling on our behalf against every democratically elected local authority, all of whom (despite regulating taxis through the advent of the engine, the radio, the telephone, the mobile phone and the internet) are running a corrupt, outdated licensing regime at the behest of the taxi industry and/or to preserve their own jobs. Is that the story here?

Or is the story that Uber wants to lock up the taxi market and build a two tier business: 0.1% of their operation earning multi-million dollar payouts, and the remaining 99.9% earning $COMMODITIZED_RATE [0] per hour driving passengers around with zero opportunity to manage drivers, open their own taxi firm, or form a collective.

The honest truth is I don't actually know. The times I've used Uber I've loved it, but I'm not sure, overall, how I feel about well-funded startups using VC money to basically buy their way around local regulation.

[0] We're seeing artificially low fares and high wages at the moment in this landgrab. Just look at eBay with fees that come to a good 10% of sales prices to see what a few more rounds of investment and a flotation will do.

Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by forrestthewoods on Sunday October 26, 2014 @06:53PM (#8512839)
I can safely say that the situation is complicated enough that neither you described is true.

Taxi regulation is corrupt and broken. I can't find a link but Seattle basically hasn't issued any new taxi medallions in 20 years. Suffice to say the area has grown significantly in that time.

Uber's business strategy is also derived from those medallions. I think they could offer a better service that is more efficient and higher margins if the drivers were Uber employees. Right now each drivers needs to be profitable by themselves. There's no room for loss leaders or any other kind of driver distribution strategy.

That's just two points. There are dozens more that could be made I'm sure.

Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by rayiner on Sunday October 26, 2014 @09:07PM (#8513260)
> Taxi regulation is corrupt and broken.

Maybe, but I think taxi regulation is harder than it seems at first blush. My experience with Uber, in D.C., has been abysmal. The drivers just don't know what they're doing or where they're going. I'll punch in my location, the app will tell me a driver will pick me up in 4 minutes, and 15 minutes later after circling the block, I might be on my way. Yeah yeah, reputation economy or whatever, but it doesn't actually work. The Uber driver I get is whichever one accepts my hail. When the ETA immediately jumps 5 minutes longer after my hail is accepted, from what the app estimated, what am I supposed to do, cancel and find a better one and waste more time? After all, if I weren't in a hurry, I wouldn't be calling a cab!

The existing regulatory infrastructure isn't perfect, but I'm very skeptical of the ability of technology to ensure quality and safety in the taxi industry. The technology doesn't offer a good replacement for an old fashioned line of sight hail, and those drivers although rude at least know where the hell they're going.

Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by kelnos on Monday October 27, 2014 @03:02AM (#8514241)
I wonder if DC is just "special" somehow. In SF, driver arrival time is very predictable, and it's rarely more than 2-3 minutes longer than the original estimate.

My only gripe is the slew of drivers who don't know their way around the city and end up taking sub-optimal routes (because they e.g. don't know where heavy traffic tends to congregate, and they're using a dumb GPS rather than something like Waze). It's also a little annoying to get in the car and wait a minute or two while they fiddle with their GPS. The recent feature that lets you enter your destination in pre-pickup has made this a little better, but not perfect.

The technology doesn't offer a good replacement for an old fashioned line of sight hail

For SF, it's completely the opposite. Trying to hail a cab, even in a heavily-trafficked area, is abysmally painful.

Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by rayiner on Monday October 27, 2014 @08:36AM (#8515087)
I've never tried to hail a cab in SF. In NYC/Chicago/Philly, catching a cab in the CBD or a major residential through fare takes a few minutes, and often just seconds. DC and Baltimore are sleepier, but in the CBD catching a cab during business hours is quick. In that context Uber isn't a replacement for cabs. It's an alternative to calling for a car when you're in a part of town without good cab service or after hours. Uber doesn't make the street hail cab system obsolete, at least as long as youre not talking about a dysfunctional place like SF.
Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by brk on Sunday October 26, 2014 @09:52PM (#8513377)
The unpredictability of driver arrival time is starting to turn me off as well. I'm finding it highly inconsistent, in multiple countries.

The common driver also seems rather clueless lately. It used to be that you were getting guys who had a day job as a limo driver and they did Uber to make some extra cash. So, they basically knew their way around and how to handle things. Recently I get more drivers that are nice/helpful, but ultimately clueless about how to navigate the area they drive in effectively.

Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by AlexMuir on Sunday October 26, 2014 @06:57PM (#8512857)
I agree absolutely. I've no experience of medallion systems but they seem clearly ridiculous. I do see the argument for quota systems that enable limit licence numbers to keep wages at a level where drivers are incentivised to maintain their cars and work a 40-hour week.

I suppose my complaint is that every dispute seems to be unquestioningly painted as Good (Uber) vs Evil (Council, State, Government, Police).

Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by smsm42 on Sunday October 26, 2014 @11:09PM (#8513568)
If side X tries to bring new service wildly popular with customers, universally voluntarily chosen by providers, providing better prices and better service, and side Y tries to prevent them from doing this citing arbitrary laws and interests of entrenched lobbying rent-seekers, having nothing to do with actual service-providers and mostly relying on FUD and denying choice to the customers - is that big of a stretch to paint side X as "good" and side Y as "evil"?

If somebody tells me "you can not buy service from X because I compete with X and I want to charge you more while providing crappy service and I know you won't ever choose me voluntarily, so I'll buy a politician and make him take your choice away" - why would not I tell such a person "you are evil, go away!"?

Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by chimeracoder on Sunday October 26, 2014 @07:58PM (#8513065)
> I can't find a link but Seattle basically hasn't issued any new taxi medallions in 20 years. Suffice to say the area has grown significantly in that time.

Medallions are largely a red herring. Municipalities vary, and I can't speak to Seattle, but for example, New York also is in a similar situation (the number of medallions has not increased commensurately with the increase in population since 1970).

However, you do not need to own a medallion in order to drive a car, just as you do not need to own storefront real estate in order to operate a retail business. You can rent medallions, and many (most?) drivers do this[1].

In addition, you don't need to either rent or own a medallion in order to drive a cab - you just can't take street hails. (These cabs are regulated as well, but differently from yellow[0] medallion cabs)

The medallions are a very common talking point, and it always irritates me because it's such a misleading statement. Medallions are not the barrier to entry for individuals who want to start driving professionally.

[0] Or green medallion cabs, which were introduced last year.

[1] They also often aren't driving their own cars, which is something that Uber/Lyft/etc. ignore - if you don't already have a car to drive (or in Uber's case, the right kind of car), you're out of luck.

Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by aaronbrethorst on Sunday October 26, 2014 @08:44PM (#8513203)

    Medallions are largely a red herring.
Agreed. Here in Seattle, the biggest issues have been:

1. It's almost impossible to find a taxi outside of a couple specific areas of town (downtown, and the commercial cores of Capitol Hill and Fremont on weekend nights), which means you're going to have to call a dispatcher.

2. The unbelievable ineptitude and rudeness of the Yellow Cab dispatchers in Seattle.

3. The historical unwillingness of Seattle taxi drivers to accept credit cards, which bears some additional unpacking. Seattle is a very credit card-friendly city. I can go weeks without visiting an ATM and not change a thing about my daily routine. However, taxi drivers used to be very hostile to accepting credit cards. I've had a couple who refused to take plastic, and actually drove me to an ATM (on my dime) to make me get cash to pay them. To their credit, on the few occasions I've had to use a taxi since UberX launched, I've found them more than happy to accept credit cards through Square.

My use of Uber is almost entirely driven by my loathing for Seattle's Yellow Cab.

Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by bilalq on Sunday October 26, 2014 @09:50PM (#8513371)
Those last two points really resonate with me and several other people I've spoken to about the topic.

I live next door to a hotel in downtown, so getting a taxi is even quicker and more convenient for me than calling Uber or Lyft. However, the incredible rudeness of cabbies and repeatedly being driven to an ATM because their credit card reader is mysteriously "broken" have pretty much dissuaded me from ever taking a regular cab again.

Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by chimeracoder on Sunday October 26, 2014 @11:23PM (#8513609)
> and repeatedly being driven to an ATM because their credit card reader is mysteriously "broken" have pretty much dissuaded me from ever taking a regular cab again.

In most cities, (incl. SF and NYC), if their machine is broken and they do not tell you before your ride starts, your ride is free.

I've never had this issue in NYC, but in SF I found that reminding the drivers of this is the best way to magically "fix" the machine. And if that doesn't work, well, hey, free cab ride!

Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by eli on Sunday October 26, 2014 @11:14PM (#8513582)
At least here in DC the drivers kinda got hosed on credit cards. they have to buy a machine + processor from an approved government vendor at above market rates. And it can take 45 days to actually get your money. That's a huge deal if you're living at or close to paycheck to paycheck.
Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by FireBeyond on Monday October 27, 2014 @12:08AM (#8513765)
Yes and no. For the first 45 days it'd suck. But after that, assuming you're working regularly, your income stream is about as steady as you'd expect - just delayed from the original date.
Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by smsm42 on Sunday October 26, 2014 @11:15PM (#8513586)
You do not need to own a medallion, and given current medallion prices, you probably can't since if you can afford a medallion you are a millionaire and millionaires rarely drive taxis. You have to rent one though. And to pay for it. And that creates an artificial limit to the market and artificial rent extracted by medallion owner - now you pay for taxi service proper and also pay the rent to medallion owner, who produces absolutely nothing and charges just for being there. Real estate is physically limited, but even then you can build your store in different places and people still can come there. Medallion means either you rent it or you are out of business. It's like all NY real estate would be build in 70s and after that, nobody would be allowed to build anything, despite growing population and expanding business. Can you imagine what that would do to a city?
Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by smokeyj on Sunday October 26, 2014 @07:00PM (#8512864)
> Is that the story here?

As opposed to your mental narrative where the taxi industry represents democracy. Because the public collectively decided they can't handle the freedom of choosing their transportation. Why thank you wise regulators, for my brain is too little to understand the dangers of choice.

Re:PPA Impounds UberX Vehicles in Undercover Sting Operation by forgotpasswd3x on Sunday October 26, 2014 @07:36PM (#8512969)
>As opposed to your mental narrative where the taxi industry represents democracy.

That's not what he said.