I may not work in IT but I crave well-written accounts of technical problem solving. Yours are among the most interesting as you're so open about sharing details that no one else would consider releasing.
Awww, you are so kind you make us blush. :-)
I do wonder why big companies like Google and Yahoo and Apple don't release more interesting statistics on drive failure. I've heard many people assume they are getting some sweet pricing on hard drives with an agreement never to release those numbers. But if that were true, why won't Seagate or Western Digital or HGST ever give Backblaze a deal to shut us up? Those three companies have refuse to sell to Backblaze "directly" (their business plan is to sell to distributors like Ingram who mark up the product and sell it to NewEgg who marks up the product and sells to Backblaze). I assure you, there are no backroom undisclosed pricing deals for Backblaze.
So I suspect Google and Apple pay retail drive prices also, and is not disclosing drive failure rates because they don't see the profit in it?
The NAS problem isn't a technical one, it is a pricing problem. We charge a fixed amount of money "per computer" ($5) and we don't throttle or limit customers in any way. We survive on "averages" - most laptop users only have less than 1 TByte and we make money, some have 50 TBytes and we lose money, but on average we are profitable.
If we allowed a single user for $5 to mount network drives with Petabytes of data on them and back those up, this would tip the averages and put us out of business. So we need to solve the pricing problem.
With all that said, stay tuned, we are actively trying to figure out a pricing system that will make everybody happy (NAS owners with Petabytes of data included).
I'd be happy to pay a premium (way over the $5 per computer) for something like that -- I'm sure I'm not alone. Extra if the software was released under the AGPL or something -- so that I could migrate to self-host if I wanted/needed to. I don't think too many would be able to start up and compete directly with you wrt your experience with pods etc... so I think it should be viable. Less sure if anyone would "want" to move off Amazon.