News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chimpanzee Intelligence Is Heritable [pdf] by ytturbed on Sunday October 26, 2014 @02:32PM (#8511812)
Fascinating stuff but the concept of intelligence is rather nebulous. Their operational definition is cobbled together from things that people have intuitively considered important like eye tracking and tool use. But these aren't connected to any deeper explanatory theories. Personally I'd be inclined to selectively breed chimps on the basis of how well they follow instructions (since instructions are perforce couched in abstract symbols and language is the quintessentially human trait).
Re:Chimpanzee Intelligence Is Heritable [pdf] by jsnk on Sunday October 26, 2014 @03:54PM (#8512110)
I feel like every chatter about intelligence comes down to arguing over the operational definition of intelligence. Isn't it obvious that abilities such as simple arithmetics, memory, linguistic ability, recognizing patterns have at least something to do with intelligence?
Re:Chimpanzee Intelligence Is Heritable [pdf] by ytturbed on Sunday October 26, 2014 @04:29PM (#8512274)
No, it's not obvious. If it were then we'd have programmed an AGI by now.
Re:Chimpanzee Intelligence Is Heritable [pdf] by JamesArgo on Sunday October 26, 2014 @04:39PM (#8512314)
So basically, we can't make a photodetector without first being able to create a sun?
Re:Chimpanzee Intelligence Is Heritable [pdf] by ytturbed on Sunday October 26, 2014 @04:50PM (#8512349)
We can't measure things we don't understand. Note that a photodetector detects light, not suns.
Re:Chimpanzee Intelligence Is Heritable [pdf] by JamesArgo on Sunday October 26, 2014 @04:57PM (#8512375)
>We can't measure things we don't understand.

What? Was everyone blind before the discovery of quantum mechanics? If we can't measure things we don't understand, how the heck would we come to understand them? Through their affects on the world? "No, you say, "we can not perceive things whose causes we don't understand." Where did you get your epistemology? Was it The Secret?

Re:Chimpanzee Intelligence Is Heritable [pdf] by ytturbed on Sunday October 26, 2014 @05:04PM (#8512406)
>Where did you get your epistemology?

Karl Popper.

>If we can't measure things we don't understand, how the heck would we come to understand them?

We get new ideas, such as the concept of distance, by guessing them in response to problems.

Re:Chimpanzee Intelligence Is Heritable [pdf] by wyager on Sunday October 26, 2014 @03:49PM (#8512086)
>how well they follow instructions

It is possible to be intelligent and unwilling to follow instructions. In fact, I would not be surprised if there was an inverse correlation between the two in humans.

Re:Chimpanzee Intelligence Is Heritable [pdf] by ytturbed on Sunday October 26, 2014 @04:26PM (#8512259)
>It is possible to be intelligent and unwilling to follow instructions

True. But whether an instruction has been followed is easy to measure and relates directly to language, unlike the other criteria in Table 1.

Also, note that chimps are capable of tearing limbs from humans. So if people could be bred from them I would like them to be basically friendly and cooperative.