News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wikipedia needs an IDE, not a WYSIWYG editor by Animats on Saturday October 25, 2014 @03:16AM (#8507492)
The basic reason that Wikipedia editing is down is that most of the job is done. The goal was to produce a reasonably comprehensive encyclopedia. Mission accomplished. Most of the important articles were written years ago. Take a look at new articles being created. They are mostly about very minor subjects.

This was typical of the paper encyclopedias. The initial creation of the Encyclopedia Brittanica was a huge job. The periodic maintenance update was a far smaller one.

Re:Wikipedia needs an IDE, not a WYSIWYG editor by dingaling on Saturday October 25, 2014 @07:48AM (#8507919)
> Mission accomplished. Most of the important articles were written years ago.

I would contend that should be leading to more edits. Few people have the depth of knowledge of expertise to contribute to 'US Foreign Policy' article, but masses can contribute to an article about their home town.

For example, the article on my town doesn't even explain its unusal name. At least half of its residents could make that particular edit... but have no incentive to do so.

Re:Wikipedia needs an IDE, not a WYSIWYG editor by _delirium on Saturday October 25, 2014 @08:38AM (#8508033)
> At least half of its residents could make that particular edit

What proportion could/would actually cite a source for the edit, though? It's likely not that hard to find a source: the local library probably has some local-history books that explain the source of the name. But in my experience the proportion of people willing to open a book before making an edit is smallish. There are some local "edit-a-thons" trying to improve that, though. I've never been to one myself, but from what I can tell they tend to be organized at libraries or universities, and the organizers have already pulled out some relevant reference materials, so people can more easily start making cited improvements to articles about their local area.

Re:Wikipedia needs an IDE, not a WYSIWYG editor by alialkhatib on Saturday October 25, 2014 @03:50AM (#8507539)
Most non-English versions of Wikipedia have dramatically less content than the English language version, and even the more common language versions like Spanish seem to be significantly less accurate. Make whatever claims you want about what role we should play in English hegemony (blah blah blah), but that's one feature Wikipedia affords where the job is far from done.
Re:Wikipedia needs an IDE, not a WYSIWYG editor by _delirium on Saturday October 25, 2014 @06:05AM (#8507744)
That's true, but also a different situation with different data: many of the non-English versions do not have a similar decline in edits. The total size of the English Wikipedia seems to be slowly plateauing, but many others still have approximately linear growth.
Re:Wikipedia needs an IDE, not a WYSIWYG editor by emw on Saturday October 25, 2014 @09:19AM (#8508119)
That point is worth making.

Sociological issues among established Wikipedia editors do contribute do lower retention of desirable new editors, but like Animats I suspect Wikipedia's comprehensive coverage is a significant factor (perhaps more so). It's simply less appealing to do curatorial work than to make large additions to major articles like "Genetics" or "France".

Which factor contributes more to Wikipedia's active editors drop-off, sociological issues or encyclopedic completeness? Has anyone looked at that? I'd be interested to see an analysis of how the trends in the notorious graph at http://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Enwp_retention_vs_act... correlate with word count and reference count in important articles.