News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ello Raises $5.5M, Legally Files as Public Benefit Corp. by gk1 on Thursday October 23, 2014 @11:35AM (#8498703)
I still don't understand what value Ello brings. It seems to be a social media network for the sake of being a social media network.

Myspace let young people (and then everyone) connect online, share photos, and declare who's their friend.

Facebook let young people (and then everyone) chat with and follow their classmates, and eventually let everyone keep in touch (using that phrase loosely) after graduation.

Ello let's -- uh, let's say tech-savvy 20- and 30-somethings? -- do -- uh, let's say send messages? -- without seeing ads.

The mission statement is equally vague.

"Ello is a simple, beautiful, ad-free social network."

Re:Ello Raises $5.5M, Legally Files as Public Benefit Corp. by amirmc on Thursday October 23, 2014 @12:02PM (#8498880)
Your descriptions about Myspace and Facebook are post-hoc. It's easy once something grows big to retrospectively say {Service} let {certain people} do {something} in {some way} (e.g. I recall music being a thing for all my friends on Myspace). When something is small, it's not always clear how things will pan out or what direction they may take.

Misson statements are always vague in some sense. "Organise the world's information" was probably strange once upon a time.

Re:Ello Raises $5.5M, Legally Files as Public Benefit Corp. by gk1 on Thursday October 23, 2014 @12:08PM (#8498922)
I think the benefit of FB was very clear from the beginning: Connect with people from your campus. I remember signing up for that exact reason, beginning of freshman year, after realizing that many other classmates were on it.
Re:Ello Raises $5.5M, Legally Files as Public Benefit Corp. by amirmc on Thursday October 23, 2014 @12:22PM (#8499018)
Indeed, and I recall there being only rudimentary profiles and I'm not even sure there was messaging functionality. You had to actively visit people's profiles to see what they were up to and had to follow conversations from wall to wall. We all signed up but we jokingly referred to it as Stalkerbook.

In other words, it was nothing like it is today, where it has become a replacement for a bunch of existing things (e.g maintaing address books) and allowed a slew of new things (light touch contact, wider networks and news feeds).

Re:Ello Raises $5.5M, Legally Files as Public Benefit Corp. by lobotryas on Thursday October 23, 2014 @11:43AM (#8498751)
Ello has a few USPs as I understand:

1. They let you choose any name you want (none of the "real name" stuff)

2. They are very friendly, focused and responsive to the needs of LGBT community

3. No ads (and thus less incentive to data mine the users, one hopes)

4. They simply don't have the history of Facebook and co

5. At least right now they are young, hip and very exclusive with invite-only membership (unlike Facebook that has everyone AND your grandma)

Re:Ello Raises $5.5M, Legally Files as Public Benefit Corp. by andygates on Thursday October 23, 2014 @11:54AM (#8498832)
>4. They simply don't have the history of Facebook and co

They're new. It's hard to get history yet. That's not a USP unless you're easily bamboozled by the latest shiny.

Re:Ello Raises $5.5M, Legally Files as Public Benefit Corp. by hobofan on Thursday October 23, 2014 @11:50AM (#8498800)
> 2. They are very friendly, focused and responsive to the needs of LGBT community

What special needs does the LGBT community have, that are not being filled by other social networks?

Re:Ello Raises $5.5M, Legally Files as Public Benefit Corp. by eroncanc on Thursday October 23, 2014 @12:03PM (#8498884)
I'm not sure if Ello solves this, but facebook took a really long time to allow _some_ gender-neutral pronouns. Some people would like to define their own.

Also, transgender people had some issues with facebook recently. [1]

[1] http://www.cnn.com/2014/09/16/living/facebook-name-policy/

Re:Ello Raises $5.5M, Legally Files as Public Benefit Corp. by jliptzin on Thursday October 23, 2014 @11:57AM (#8498855)
I am gay and even I don't know the answer to that question
Re:Ello Raises $5.5M, Legally Files as Public Benefit Corp. by sedachv on Thursday October 23, 2014 @04:45PM (#8500639)
There's some kind of homophobic troll(s) reporting drag queens' profiles in violation of Facebook's real name policy: http://www.towleroad.com/2014/10/facebook-continues-to-freez... The content moderators (good article on them in the current issue of Wired: http://www.wired.com/2014/10/content-moderation/) are suspending the accounts.
Re:Ello Raises $5.5M, Legally Files as Public Benefit Corp. by GuiA on Thursday October 23, 2014 @11:47AM (#8498781)
But none of these points solve any problem. They're "features" of the product, but what is the product for?
Re:Ello Raises $5.5M, Legally Files as Public Benefit Corp. by sanderjd on Thursday October 23, 2014 @11:56AM (#8498846)
Put in your terms:

Ello lets somewhat older young people (and probably eventually everyone) chat with and follow their friends, acquaintances, and people they find interesting, without needing to use their real identity or make their private data available to advertisers.

The market definitely exists, but is probably quite a bit smaller than the facebook market, and people have tried and failed to tap it in the past. Its time may have come due to the various real name policy backlashes against other services. It's also very possible that it will run into the same brick wall as everyone else who has tried this has.

Re:Ello Raises $5.5M, Legally Files as Public Benefit Corp. by mcintyre1994 on Thursday October 23, 2014 @01:49PM (#8499594)
Regarding number 3, are they actually committed to not data mining their users for commercial purposes? Because if not, they're not selling ads - isn't the incentive to instead sell that data to the highest bidder?
Re:Ello Raises $5.5M, Legally Files as Public Benefit Corp. by atwebb on Thursday October 23, 2014 @11:53AM (#8498824)
All of those sound like initial selling points of FB.
Re:Ello Raises $5.5M, Legally Files as Public Benefit Corp. by ijk on Thursday October 23, 2014 @11:44AM (#8498757)
I read it as a kind of a second-generation solution: it takes a previously solved problem (a social network) and tries to solve a perceived problem with the existing solutions.

Whether it succeeds or fails will hinge on if there is a market for something that has similar features to Facebook/Twitter but solves a problem that people have been objecting to.

Re:Ello Raises $5.5M, Legally Files as Public Benefit Corp. by enraged_camel on Thursday October 23, 2014 @12:00PM (#8498874)
>> Myspace let young people (and then everyone) connect online, share photos, and declare who's their friend.

Don't forget that it also allowed significant customization of user homepages, up to and including embedding music. Sure it got annoying sometimes, but it also added a lot of excitement to the experience. Things felt very... wild wild west.

Re:Ello Raises $5.5M, Legally Files as Public Benefit Corp. by spindritf on Thursday October 23, 2014 @11:40AM (#8498729)
It allows people to signal that they care about privacy, their data, and stand against commercialism. Both the users, and the operators.

It's like asking "what value does Nike/TapouT/Starbucks logo have?" Sure, you can get better coffee for less, but good coffee is not really what they're selling.

Re:Ello Raises $5.5M, Legally Files as Public Benefit Corp. by gk1 on Thursday October 23, 2014 @11:53AM (#8498819)
I can understand what Starbucks or Nike are selling... I'm just trying to figure out what exactly Ello is selling. So far, all I can find is "beautiful" and "ad-free."

Standing against commercialism sounds very noble, but a very small percentage of my friends and family care enough about that to jump ship to a new social network.