News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by rdl on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @06:21AM (#8492102)
I'm maybe a bit more libertarian than most HN readers, which is already a bit more libertarian than most people (especially Europeans), but when I do support taxes, I'd rather they be as broad-based as possible, unless they're targeting something which has negative externalities.

Universally applied VAT is (aside from the data-collection requirements) proven to be one of the least economically distorting taxes -- creating the least deadweight loss.

This tax seems almost pathologically bad -- taxing something with largely positive externalities. Normally you try "sin taxes" which tax things reviewed as having NEGATIVE externalities (CO2, smoking, even unhealthy foods).

It's like taxing people for reading books, or for volunteering their time to useful charities, or for picking up litter on the street. Actively discouraging something which has positive returns to society as a whole when people use more of it!

Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by sliverstorm on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @03:10PM (#8494502)
It seems to me more like an infrastructure use tax, which seem to work fine. Don't you pay usage-based taxes for the public roads (via gasoline taxes)?

Now I guess the next question is, are the pipes in Hungary publicly owned.

[dead]
Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by nightcracker on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @07:33AM (#8492237)
I really hate this mindset. These businesses aren't being killed by the internet - they've simply outlived their use.

This is the risk of being a business in transport. If a cheaper, faster and more accessible form of transport comes along you go out of business. Not because something has killed you or your business (you are perfectly allowed to still do your business as you like), but because you aren't useful anymore.

For example the milkman disappeared with the invention of refrigerated transport. Not because the milkman was killed, but because he was no longer useful.

Please, do not defend things that are not useful.

s/milkman/CD/ s/refrigerated transport/internet file transfer/

Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by flexie on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @07:45AM (#8492250)
I agree, but I'm no milkman.

Amazon (books etc), Google and Facebook (advertising), Apple (music and movies), and many other Internet companies take jobs from Hungarian voters. And as far as I remember these companies don't pay much tax.

They probably add some jobs, but if you worked in the bookstore, the advertising agency or the record store, and your job was lost to the Internet, you would be the one feeling the externalities of the Internet.

Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by allendoerfer on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @09:10AM (#8492498)
I don't know, why he is downvoted. He actually makes valid points.

The internet and globalization as a whole open possibilities for less developed countries. At the same time, they are often exposing their markets to competition they simply cannot compete with at this point.

The common argument is, that these countries should open up, catch up in education and participate in the next wave of innovation (e.g. skip the web, go directly to mobile) or learn from the faults of the first movers (e.g. European cc-payments requiring pin).

But when we look at the country arguably profiting the most from globalization, China, we find that it is massively protecting its market by requiring joint ventures with local companies and blocking internet-based companies, which could circumvent these measurements.

These points do not mean, that taxing internet traffic is the right thing to do, it just means, that not all regulations are bad. You have to look carefully at each industry. In Germany taxis are strongly regulated. Drivers get special trainings, the cars have to be checked more often than regular cars, a taxi has to accept every passenger and so on. I support them fighting Uber, which ignores these regulations and is trying to build a monopoly by competing on price. And monopolies are bad for workers and in the end customers, even if Peter Thiel wants to sell a book.

Edit: His parent comment is now dead, but you can get the context out of nightcrackers answer.

Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by tempodox on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @10:46AM (#8492922)
Right, and after losing their job those people are supposed to pay the taxes that Amazon, Apple, etc don't. Because as an out-of-work individual you're much better posed to pay taxes than a transnational company that's too rich for its own good. Sounds like a perfect Mafia scheme to me.
Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by e7620 on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @07:49AM (#8492256)

    The Internet, while most of us don't care, has negative externalities
    as well:

    - killing hundreds of thousands of businesses such as bookstores, movie
    rental stores, record stores;
    - makes it possible through IP telephony,
    email, the web, collaboration tools etc. to outsource millions of jobs;
    - is a time consumer like no other before;
With that philosophy, agriculture would still comprise 100% of the economy. Yes, everybody, even kids, would have a job, but who wants that standard of living?

Also, about wasting time on the internet, maybe for you socializing or gaming is a waste of time, but before internet people also did this, additions already existed back then you know.

    Yes, the Internet creates businesses as well but I don't think I've ever
    used a Hungarian Internet business. Also, the outsourced jobs go mainly
    to Asia. I could see why a conservative government would tax the Internet.
That's because you don't live there. When you know several languages, you see there are huge properties outside the five eyes Internet.
Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by flexie on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @07:52AM (#8492264)
It's not a philosophy. It's how politics work.

I don't think Hungary will return to pre-industrial times because of an Internet tax.

Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by e7620 on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @07:58AM (#8492273)
> I don't think Hungary will return to pre-industrial times because of an Internet tax.

It will not return but they'll be stuck there. This will have a chilling effect on the economy, and about all new jobs enabled by the internet? no new job will be created, they'll go to other countries without imposed tax barriers.

Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by flexie on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:16AM (#8492312)
Nonsense. There are hundreds of direct and indirect taxes in any modern economy. A 175 million euro tax is one of the least important ones for the economy.

Income taxes, capital gains taxes, corporate profit taxes etc. are much more important, even to most Internet companies, than the proposed Internet tax because they are much bigger.

Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by e7620 on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @08:27AM (#8492349)
Even if only one person can't use the internet because of this tax, that's more than enough reason to avoid it.
Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by m0g on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @07:30AM (#8492231)
If I'm not mistaken, prezi is hungarian and very widely used
Re:Hungary plans new tax on Internet traffic by sz4kerto on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @06:59AM (#8492171)
> I don't think I've ever used a Hungarian Internet business

There are a couple of successful ones though - Ustream is quite widely used, so is LogMeIn or LiveJasmin (webcam porn).