News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Case law is set free; what next? by rayiner on Tuesday October 21, 2014 @10:50PM (#8491301)
The digital systems are direct continuations of the paper ones. For example, federal court opinions are published on a court's website in PDF form. West Publishing collects them and prints bound volumes of the Federal Reporter. In parallel, it pulls the text of the opinions into the Westlaw online service, and incorporates the pagination of the printed versions by embedding starred page numbers into the text.

Also, West still categorizes the digital system using the index developed for paper cases. Using this index is usually faster than using search queries. In fact, search really doesn't work very well for legal research, and Google-like free form search works particularly badly (it tends to take you to highly-cited cases rather than highly-relevant ones). I generally start my research by looking up the topic in the digital version of a printed treatise or legal encyclopedia and then doing a reverse citation search of the listed cases. Failing that, I'll do low-level search queries (e.g., "foo" within N words of "bar").

But the only time I ever actually used a book was when I was working for a judge. Every now and then West screws up and the pagination differs between the digital and printed versions of the Federal Reporter. So we'd do our final cite-check using the printed volumes.

Re:Case law is set free; what next? by Animats on Wednesday October 22, 2014 @01:16AM (#8491540)
The reason the West system works is because law is retrospective. Cases cite older cases. Amendments to laws cite older laws. Much of the "annotation" involves inverting those backlinks, so you can look up legislation and find all the cases which reference it. That process is now, of course, automated.