The argument being made against the picobrew is that it takes away exactly the thing a significant portion of the home brewing community enjoys:
1)The skill required to differentiate between a good and great, reproducible, beer
2)Sharing said beer and knowing it was something you created, as opposed you just 'made'.
There's a depth and risk of failure to brewing that is simply not there with baking bread.
I think the bread maker analogy is a really good one. I'd consider buying a bread maker precisely because I don't particularly enjoy the drawn out process of baking bread, but I do enjoy both having freshly baked bread and being able to make bread with the stuff I like in it.
I have a friend who roasts his own coffee for similar reasons.
If I had to do it again, though, I'd get a smaller one. Something that can make a 1-pound loaf. My family doesn't go through 1.5 pounds in a day, and when you have a bread maker, keeping day-old bread is not an option.