News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Amazon’s Monopsony Is Not O.K. by jasode on Monday October 20, 2014 @12:34PM (#8483030)
>When one buyer represents 50-60% of sales, ... One party to the negotiation can walk away; the other cannot.

I don't follow the logic here. Your fatalistic assessment assumes Hachette (and other publishers) are paralyzed and cannot adapt. However, the business world isn't static therefore Hachette can walk away. (If not this particular contract renewal because of timing pressure then at least the next one -- if they have a smart strategy.)

If amazon has 60% of sales, it was the book publishers who willingly signed previous business deals to allow amazon to become that dominant. Likewise, those book publishers can put on their business-thinking hats and figure out how to make amazon less powerful.

Victim thinking: ok, amazon wants to pay us less for our books. Since we're helpless deer in the headlights, what do we do?

Business thinking: ok, we got our executive team in a conference room here. The CEO says, "this is where all you vice presidents and MBAs earn your salaries. Give me a business plan to lessen amazon's pricing power over us." Options:

1) Rethink/reprioritize other reseller relationships and offer better terms to Barnes & Noble, Apple iBooks, etc

2) Open our own online book store. Talk to other publishers about starting a consortium or joint venture to create a new online book store to sell direct.

3) Maybe Google Inc is also interested in partnering with us to beat amazon.

4) Call CEO of Sony and tell him we want help his eReader beat Kindle by offering exclusive titles just for that device.

5) dozens of other creative business ideas...

If all the big publishers want to, they can join forces and pull all their book titles from amazon. Amazon is then left with just the self-published CreateSpace titles. The book publishers made voluntary deals to get them into this position of weakness and likewise, they can start making voluntary strategic moves to get them out of it.

Airlines used to pay a big commission to travel agents. The airlines used the emergence of the internet to reduce commissions to agents. In this case the vendor (airlines) got more leverage than the reseller (travel agents). However, cruise ships still rely on travel agents for the bulk of their bookings. Maybe the relative positions of market power will change. Maybe not. Businesses can adapt and change if they want to.

All the articles from New York Times, salon.com, author blogs, etc sympathizing with the book publishers have not convinced me that Hachette is a helpless victim of amazon dominance.

Re:Amazon’s Monopsony Is Not O.K. by fleitz on Monday October 20, 2014 @12:40PM (#8483065)
Excellent points, whenever I read Krugman I always get the feeling that he wants everyone to be a victim so they'll support whatever government intervention he wants this week.

Hachette is a major company that has no problem fighting back, problem is in the internet age they are incompetent, for that they deserve whatever the market is dishing out to their outdated business model.

Re:Amazon’s Monopsony Is Not O.K. by ender7 on Monday October 20, 2014 @01:43PM (#8483422)
Note that some of these ideas count as collusion and are illegal. See: the Justice Department's successful lawsuit against publishers over their deals with Apple.

Unfortunately, the set of solutions {!collusion, practical} is very small. It might be empty.

Re:Amazon’s Monopsony Is Not O.K. by jasode on Monday October 20, 2014 @01:58PM (#8483524)
The illegal collusion with Apple was over coordinated price fixing.

I don't see what would be illegal about book publishers partnering up to create their own online store and making their titles exclusive to that store.

The major record labels jointly own Vevo[1] for youtube content. They also collectively own a big chunk of Spotify.

Pearson Publishing is a competitor of O'Reilly and yet they were partial owners of the O'Reilly online subscription system.[2]

[1]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Vevo

[2]http://www.oreilly.com/pub/pr/3216

Re:Amazon’s Monopsony Is Not O.K. by exelius on Monday October 20, 2014 @05:14PM (#8484541)
Joint ventures almost never pan out; especially for content. Once you create a joint venture, none of the partners have full control. That means decisions need to be made by consensus. It's hard to have consensus on a regular basis with one of your competitors. Do it too much and it's anticompetitive; don't do it enough and you'll never get anything dine.

If your company is relying on a joint venture to save its future, you should probably update your resume...

Re:Amazon’s Monopsony Is Not O.K. by WalterBright on Monday October 20, 2014 @12:59PM (#8483158)
Note that O'Reilly books have their own site, and seem to do rather well.
Re:Amazon’s Monopsony Is Not O.K. by michaelq on Monday October 20, 2014 @01:34PM (#8483365)
O'Reilly is a specialized technical book publisher. Hatchette, on the other hand, is an undifferentiated conglomerate (one of the big 5 publishing companies). The types of people who would start their book search at O'Reilly are fairly well defined. That isn't the case with Hatchette. People on HatchetteStore.com are less likely to browse and more likely to search, and the second they fail to find a book they were looking for, they'd probably bounce back to Amazon.
Re:Amazon’s Monopsony Is Not O.K. by WalterBright on Monday October 20, 2014 @05:38PM (#8484673)
HBO seems to compete rather well against Netflix, despite Netflix having orders of magnitude more selection.
Re:Amazon’s Monopsony Is Not O.K. by jasode on Monday October 20, 2014 @06:18PM (#8484844)
Indeed, HBO's plans for direct subscribers[1] may be part of their strategy to be less dependent on the cable providers. When contracts expire and are up for renegotiation, HBO will have more leverage with Time Warner, Comcast. I think channels such as ESPN and HBO already do have quite a bit of leverage with cable providers but having their own direct link to consumers would give them even more.

To relate back to amazon, I'm guessing Jeff Bezos has to buy old HBO content at a loss to fill out the selections for Amazon Prime Video. That way, the $99 membership fee looks like a good value. Could amazon put a price squeeze on HBO? It doesn't look like it. Amazon needs HBO content more than HBO needs Amazon.

20 years ago, HBO didn't have these type of business options. If HBO didn't like Comcast terms, it would be unrealistic for HBO to start digging streets and laying new video cables to a million residential homes. With the internet, they don't have to. I'm not convinced that book publishers have no chess moves left to use.

[1]http://deadline.com/2014/10/richard-plepler-time-warner-inve...

Re:Amazon’s Monopsony Is Not O.K. by JackC on Monday October 20, 2014 @04:01PM (#8484154)
First of all, believe me, I would love it if publishers came and asked me how to beat Amazon. A new online bookstore (with a radically different approach to DRM) would definitely be on the list. I agree with you that publishers are not necessarily beat.

But you can't wave away the power Amazon has in that fight. The number of businesses that can survive, say, a 50% drop in sales for a year is pretty darn small, and the number of businesses that will tolerate a 50% drop in sales for six months without tossing out the CEO is even smaller. That means Amazon has a lot of power right now to decide how practically every supplier in the book market behaves. And they are pushing in exactly the opposite direction with all that power -- they're trying to consolidate.

So this is dynamic in both directions -- it's a tug of war where Amazon's monopsony power will either increase or decrease. I feel like the smart money has got to be on increase. (See Amazon's P/E ratio.)

Re:Amazon’s Monopsony Is Not O.K. by awinder on Monday October 20, 2014 @01:11PM (#8483229)
"Rethink/reprioritize other reseller relationships and offer better terms to Barnes & Noble, Apple iBooks, etc"

Wasn't this exactly what happened and resulted in Amazon getting the Att. General to investigate antitrust allegations?

Re:Amazon’s Monopsony Is Not O.K. by icelancer on Monday October 20, 2014 @09:52PM (#8485546)
Besides that whole price fixing thing, sure.