As another author and Nobel laureate said[1], "everything is politics".
If the lower price really would make more money for everyone, then surely Hachette would readily do it. Since they don't, and since they understand this market as well as anyone, a reasonable person might assume that they would indeed make less money with a lower price.
Even free-market fundamentalists must see that free markets don't function when dominated by monopoly or monopsony. So isn't there a legitimate public policy question about whether the state should limit that market power?
Re:Amazon’s Monopsony Is Not O.K.
by bryanlarsen on Monday October 20, 2014 @10:05AM
(#8482171)
Lower prices increase sales and profits for Amazon because they compete against book stores.
Lower prices decrease profits for book publishers who make money both from Amazon and book stores.
Worse, the argument is over pricing on e-books, not physical stock, so Hachette's stance makes even less sense.
As usual, Paul Krugman sees everything through a political lens, so naturally Amazon is evil and must be beaten down.