The whole democratic process is just smoke and mirrors to prevent the populace from revolting - and I think we all know it - which means that it can't work as it does now for much longer - hence the increasing militarisation of police, creeping liberty reduction, and all the rest - as they know this too, and power, once attained, is clung to at pretty much any cost, by the kind of individual to whom power over others appeals.
Maybe that's the problem with western governments? They have erroneously interpreted their job to be "running the country", and the typical elected official is not qualified to do this? Perhaps they should cede the running of the country to the public service and recognise that their true role as an elected official is to keep the public service transparent, accountable and honest?
The problem with the above is that once a government sacrifices transparency, as most seem to have done, they have no useful purpose and have to resort to (incompetently) trying to run things to justify their existence.
Here's a look at one of the most extreme bureaucracies the world ever produced, it is the result of expediency and unchecked power combined with ideology over evidence; http://www.galorebot.com/bureaucracy/essay.htm
Keeping such large organisations in check requires the fortitude to keep hitting your head against a brick wall while also remaining sharp minded and sane; all the while making progress.
That's why Thomas Jefferson and others straight out of Enlightenment wanted for the Federal government top be very limited and for the law-making power to be left to the states. Each US state is much smaller than the US.
That's actually an interesting question, what sort of qualifications are needed to do a job like that
I actually think that the universe of people who could do those jobs is actually pretty large
the real limiter is that if you pick someone too far out of the box, you're going to take political fire for it
like Bush did when he tried to nominate Harriet Miers to the Supreme Court
in contrast, when you nominate a known entity, ie Clinton to Secretary of State, they have the political clout to keep unhappy hopefuls (and their bidders) quiet
I'd like to believe that, but it's not just a matter of inherent capability, talent and intelligence.
A very large part of the qualifications is experience with bureaucracies, politics, management, power-games, diplomacy. I'm talking 2 decades of experience, at least. Not the kind of stuff you can learn in school (mainly because school just doesn't last long enough), and definitely not the kind of stuff you can pick up on the job, no matter how talented and super bright somebody is.
I kind of wish it wasn't sometimes (although other times I'm not so sure of the consequences..) but the fact of the matter is that medium-smart experienced politicians are going to out-politic a super-smart rookie every time.
Except that he's dependent on them to protect his very hide. Or in the case of the heads of military and intelligence agencies, he's desperate just to have someone he can talk to. That's why he keeps hanging on to Brennan, for example.
I think anything that gives more power to the states, and unburdens the federal government from that responsibility would generally be a win-win for everybody.
In addition to the benefit of 50 petri dishes to gather data on what works and what doesn't, there's a human rights component, in that it's more feasible to move to a new state than a new country if policies are disagreeable. While not a perfect solution (especially for the poor), it does move further along the spectrum towards an active social contract, where people literally vote with their feet, rather than a passive one, where you're stuck with the rules of wherever you happen to be born.
That said, the more local the government is, the more effective and responsible it tends to be: each vote counts more, constituents resemble humans rather than numbers, and it's a more manageable scope to engage in the nitty-gritty of governance. Balancing this reality with the benefits of collective solidarity is what Charlie Stross would call a Wicked Problem [1].
[1] http://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/2011/07/wicked-1...
The quality of a president's cabinet appointments determines how well the government functions during their presidency. The problem is, where do you get 3,000 people able to perform at that level? They're usually drawn from the usual suspects. When that's not the case, the result looks like amateur hour. How many people are qualified to be Secretary of State? The pool of people who have been around enough countries and political leaders to operate at that level is small.
The role of the White House staff varies from administration to administration. Eisenhower probably had the most effective staff in many decades. He knew how to make a military staff work together, and modeled the White House on that basis. Eisenhower was very good at putting the right person in the right job. (How Eisenhower deployed Montgomery and Patton is a famous example.)
None of the recent presidents have had that kind of experience.