Re:When Those Who Know Won’t Share
by rational-future on Sunday October 19, 2014 @10:57AM
(#8478425)
> don't make people compete by limiting the prize pool
That is an interesting idea and it probably works in some rare situations. But unfortunately, most of the time, we only have limited resources and so a limited prize pool. The question, for managers/politicians/capitalists, usually is how do we get maximum motivation out of a limited rewards budget.
I don't a reason why it should work only in rare situations. This seems perfectly suited for companies - after all, you make money directly off increased productivity of each of your workers. Just keep the reward smaller than what you'd expect to gain from increased productivity, and it should be possible to sustain this system.
Re:When Those Who Know Won’t Share
by rational-future on Sunday October 19, 2014 @11:22AM
(#8478487)
I have run a few small companies (up to 30 employees/contractors), and FWIW my experience doesn't match your assumptions. At the end of a year you've made a limited amount of profit and you want to distribute part of it to the personal. The most efficient way I found is to give 80% to the few top performers - the people who work 100+ hour work weeks or have more connections (sales) or are smarter (IT). The others you can easily replace plus bonuses don't seem to increase much the productivity of the averagely lazy. Surely this is just another anecdote.
Anecdote time! When I was a student, performance scolarships at my faculty were distributed this way. There were set thresholds, and if your grade average from the previous year was above a given threshold, you got +X money in scolarship. We were all extremely cooperative. People helped each other all the time, we pooled notes, scans, bootleg textbook pdfs, previous year's exam questions, we passed this knowledge down to younger students, who in turn passed them further after adding more materials of their own. We'd happily help each other get better grades.
You bet there was a lot of us on those scolarships. And people who came from the outside were extremely surprised about how friendly and helpful everyone is.
After I left, my faculty was forced to make scolarships work the way they work at every other faculty/university - i.e. make only top X% of students eglible for rewards. This instantly killed teamwork dead. I know few people who are still studying and they say there's a clear and visible difference now. People no longer share things. They don't care about recording exam questions for others, they don't coordinate the whole year to win something. Students stick to small groups and are antagonistic to others. If they help at all, they do it to the degree it doesn't endanger their own chance for scolarships.
Incentives matter. Also greed/stupid costs savings on the part of people setting up incentive structures matter too.