Re:Some thoughts on asking for a raise
by FranOntanaya on Saturday October 18, 2014 @08:01AM
(#8475173)
I guess the part of it being a public proposal helps here. Each coworker has a mental profile of the one making the proposal, and can judge to some extent if they are the kind of person to live above their means or to work above their means. In a sense that's a knowledge value created during the day-to-day work that you just throw away if you don't apply to this HR management problem.
A lot of your examples are somewhat linked to the issue of having just one person with a very limited supply of knowledge about their staff decide on salaries.
I want a $1M /yr salary because I want to give $900k to Doctors Without Borders. Surely that is a better idea than the CTO's Tesla Roadster and Palm Springs winter house, right?
Sure, I get that it's public, and that the coworkers should know the raise-asker well enough to understand where they're are coming from, but I still don't get how the "personal needs" thing should factor in at all. The living-within-one's-means thing was just an example. There are tons of reasons why you might want more money, but very few where you actually need it, assuming you've made reasonably good financial choices up to that point. And yeah, even with the best intentions regarding money, sometimes people still get kicked in the ass, but I still question if "having some bad luck with money" is a reasonable justification for giving someone a raise. I'm fairly convinced it isn't.
I'm not sure the one-person-decides bit really applies here. I object to "personal needs" being used as evidence for or against giving someone a raise, regardless of whether it's one person making the decision or many, or whether it's made by someone who knows the person and their work deeply, or only has superficial knowledge. I just don't think that matters for this particular case.
Oof. Not sure how I feel about this rationale. If I were the other guy in this equation, I'd be pissed if I was making the same contribution as someone else, but got paid less because the other guy "needed it more". Why am I being punished because I live within my means?
Maybe the response to, "I need a higher salary because I have a large mortgage payment", should be, "maybe you shouldn't have bought a larger house than you could afford".
How about this: say this guy works at your company, and presents this rationale, and gets (takes?) his raise. Then the other guy, who is (for the sake of the argument) exactly equal in experience and skill, and provides the same value to your company, steps up to the plate and says, "I would like a raise as well, because I should make the same amount as someone who is my equal and peer". Would the group agree with that? I certainly hope so. If I were that guy, I'd quit on the spot if not.
And this extends to other things as well: one guy has 4 kids, the other has 2. Kids can be expensive. Does the first guy's decision to have more kids make him more deserving of a higher salary than the other guy?
I could extend this to just about anything. In the end, once you're above the poverty line, your "needs" aren't really based on anything rational or "fair". It's really just what you want. I'm not saying you shouldn't try to get what you want, but suggesting that one person's wants entitles them to a higher salary than someone who has more modest wants... well, that's ridiculous to me.
This is actually a great example of one of the reasons why employers like to keep compensation secret. If this hypothetical high-mortgage guy is that important to the company, you want to be able to give him more money if not doing so will cause him to quit, all without pissing off the other otherwise-equal guy with the now-lower salary.
So my thesis here, I guess, is that if you're going to be transparent about compensation, that compensation must be based on measures as objective as you can make them. Otherwise you have to keep compensation secret so you can make "unfair" deals with some employees as necessary, without pissing off other employees who don't get such a good deal.
At any rate, I do think what you're doing is a really cool (and brave!) experiment. I hope it works out for you and your company, but I'm very much afraid that making personal needs a component of public compensation decisions will lead to others harboring resentment.