News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Some thoughts on asking for a raise by cheepin on Saturday October 18, 2014 @04:45AM (#8474953)
> I also believe most employers are not trying to screw you or underpay you.

This is something I hear contradicted here quite a bit. As someone who hasn't been in the industry a long time, I'm interested in hearing more about why this is or isn't true.

Re:Some thoughts on asking for a raise by paulsutter on Saturday October 18, 2014 @04:51AM (#8474968)
TL/DR: IF YOU WANT A GOOD RAISE, GET A COMPETING OFFER.

It's absolutely true. Employers really don't want to screw employees, they just have no true measure of your value. They have to use your most recent pay, YOUR OTHER OFFERS, industry stats, and a biased set of personal anecdotes to ballpark a placeholder when you get hired, because there really is no other information.

Once you are hired, your manager never thinks about your salary. Until he has to, like annual reviews. OR YOU HAVE A COMPETING OFFER. And during annual reviews, he's given one bucket of raise that he needs to divvy up among his staff. There isn't a lot to go around, nor any way to handle special cases.

That's just the way it works. If you want a good raise, get a competing offer.

Re:Some thoughts on asking for a raise by vinceguidry on Saturday October 18, 2014 @05:49AM (#8475026)
I've heard this advocated a lot, but I find it hard to do in the case where you really don't want to leave your company, but do need to correct your salary. Because it requires engaging with other companies on less than good faith that you're really motivated to jump to another job. Sure, if you're a sociopath, this won't be a problem for you.

As someone in this exact position, my solution was to ask for a raise, and when they said no, I considered trying to make a quick move. But after realizing that I really don't want to job hunt right this moment, I put my head down and went back to work.

I think in order to get to that point in your career where you can easily have multiple competing offers to choose from, you need to be a really good developer with a spiffy-looking portfolio. Takes time to get there, and beating the bushes to get offers just doesn't appeal to me, and probably won't until I've fine-tuned my development process to where I can whip up websites like no tomorrow. My job is Good Enough for the moment, yours might be too if you think about it.

Oh and parent comment presented his opinion as a TL:DR of the OP, when in fact it's just his opinion. The OP is nuanced and quite worth the read.

Re:Some thoughts on asking for a raise by kelnos on Saturday October 18, 2014 @07:32AM (#8475136)
... it requires engaging with other companies on less than good faith that you're really motivated to jump to another job.

This is what bothers me most about this sort of advice. As someone who is often trying to hire people, it's a lot of effort to get a candidate through the pipeline to the point where an offer is made. Intentionally causing people at another company to waste that kind of effort would make me feel like I was doing something unethical. I really don't think you should look for a competing offer unless you're willing to accept that offer if you don't get what you want from your current employer.

As someone in this exact position, my solution was to ask for a raise, and when they said no, I considered trying to make a quick move. But after realizing that I really don't want to job hunt right this moment, I put my head down and went back to work.

Yeah, I think that's just the value judgment everyone has to make. Either you get another offer and are willing to walk if it's not met, or you're willing to wait it out and see if you can get a better raise later. It's a personal decision based on your circumstances.

Oh and parent comment presented his opinion as a TL:DR of the OP, when in fact it's just his opinion. The OP is nuanced and quite worth the read.

I think the parent was actually tl;dr'ing his own post up front.

Re:Some thoughts on asking for a raise by sheepmullet on Saturday October 18, 2014 @08:40AM (#8475223)
"As someone who is often trying to hire people, it's a lot of effort to get a candidate through the pipeline to the point where an offer is made."

Then make sure your staff aren't forced to get a competing offer just to get market rates.

"Intentionally causing people at another company to waste that kind of effort would make me feel like I was doing something unethical"

The vast majority of people applying for roles will switch if the offer is right. Sure if you offer 10% more I'd much rather just get my current employer to match... but if you offer 30+% then we have a deal. I don't want to stay with an employer who will underpay me by so much.

Re:Some thoughts on asking for a raise by kelnos on Monday October 20, 2014 @06:13AM (#8481396)
Then make sure your staff aren't forced to get a competing offer just to get market rates.

I'm not sure what this has to do with what I said. I'm talking about the cost in time and effort to hire someone, not to retain them. (Regardless, I have no say or control over salaries, so I can't do much about this.)

The vast majority of people applying for roles will switch if the offer is right. Sure if you offer 10% more I'd much rather just get my current employer to match... but if you offer 30+% then we have a deal. I don't want to stay with an employer who will underpay me by so much.

Eh, maybe. I'm not sure I agree. Even if I was feeling underpaid at my current company, it'd have to be a ridiculously sweet deal to get me to move (I mean, so sweet that no one would ever offer me something like that). I have enough forms of attachment other than salary that even say a 50% raise would be unlikely to get me to budge. I think there are quite a few people who feel similarly.

And that's what I object to: someone shopping around with zero intention of accepting another job, but only doing so to use as leverage with their current employer. Yeah, "it's just business", but the people at these other companies whose time you're wasting are real people who don't deserve to be jerked around.

Re:Some thoughts on asking for a raise by vinceguidry on Saturday October 18, 2014 @09:07AM (#8475256)
Yeah, I think we're on the same page here. It does create a weird conundrum that makes a lot of people want to solve with asinine and borderline unethical logic. You know you should be making more than you are, but your employer just won't see that. The easy assumption to make is that your employer is being sociopathic and that you should be more sociopathic in return. "It's just business!"

But the stakes are really high here. Your employer has a lot more to lose than you do if you jump ship over a relatively small amount of money. You took the job, so obviously it was right for you at some point. Did that really change just because they turned your raise request down? Do you really want to hang them out to dry over what's essentially a misunderstanding? Don't sacrifice your professionalism to feed your ego.

My solution is to just keep getting better and better until I can make my own opportunities. Then to start on one as my current projects wind down, giving plenty of notice as to my intentions. Everybody wins.

> I think the parent was actually tl;dr'ing his own post up front.

Ah, right.

Re:Some thoughts on asking for a raise by HeyLaughingBoy on Saturday October 18, 2014 @10:20AM (#8475360)
I'm going to show an opposing viewpoint here: I believe this is the thought pattern that screws developers over.

It's not about being sociopathic. You said it yourself: it's just business. Really, that's what it is. You are exchanging skills for money, if one party isn't happy with the agreement, they can terminate it. Don't confuse the issue with wording like "hang them out to dry" or "professionalism." Professionalism has nothing to do with martyring yourself. If you're unhappy with anything enough to leave, then leave.

Re:Some thoughts on asking for a raise by kelnos on Monday October 20, 2014 @06:17AM (#8481403)
I agree with what you're saying, but that isn't what we're talking about here. We're talking about the idea of it being unethical to shop yourself around with no intention of accepting a competing company's offer. I see this as ethically neutral with respect to your current employer, but as kinda unethical with respect to the other companies whose time, effort, and resources you are wasting by pushing yourself through a hiring pipeline with no intention of following through.

If you can get a better deal from your current employer via other means, you should certainly do so. If not... well, I'm personally uncomfortable interviewing at other companies with no intention of accepting an offer. Opinions differ, of course.

Re:Some thoughts on asking for a raise by vinceguidry on Saturday October 18, 2014 @11:06AM (#8475458)
> If you're unhappy with anything enough to leave, then leave.

I wasn't unhappy enough to leave. That's why I didn't leave.

Re:Some thoughts on asking for a raise by tobz on Saturday October 18, 2014 @11:16AM (#8475480)
The article, and this comment thread, is definitely heavy on the money factor, but there's also the everything-other-than-money compensation aspect mentioned in the article as well.

I find it really hard to try and figure out what other benefits, aside from a salary hike, you might get from a new job. Realistically, I think you need to make your way right up until the point where they do or don't offer you something. Everything about the interview process is as much of the company seeing if they like you as it is you seeing if you like the company.

Sure, if you have no intention of changing your employment situation, well, yeah, you're wasting a bit of someone else's time... but there's also the flipside that you might not even notice that there's something more interesting, or something intrinsically more valuable, about a new job until you actually get to the point where you're being offered it.

Re:Some thoughts on asking for a raise by kelnos on Monday October 20, 2014 @06:19AM (#8481409)
That's a really good point that I haven't considered. I guess the key point is there that our hypothetical raise-seeker isn't really too interested in a change, but at least has an open mind and would consider making a jump if something unexpectedly great popped up during the process.
Re:Some thoughts on asking for a raise by judk on Saturday October 18, 2014 @12:13PM (#8475627)
Do you think your employer feels bad about soliciting 3 bids for a vendor contract? In many cases not doing so is illegal!

Same with your job.

Re:Some thoughts on asking for a raise by ownagefool on Saturday October 18, 2014 @08:50AM (#8475234)
I sorta feel the same way about it that you do, I really wouldn't take interviews that far unless I was at least somewhat inclined in taking the offer.

However, employers don't particularly care about their candidates either. Generally you're expected to skip a day of getting paid, at crappy notice, to come talk to some people who've laregly already made their minds up about you.

You might be the special case that doesn't treat candidates like shit, but after a while of getting stiffed, most people learn to play the game. I can't really blame people for trying to get what they're worth.

I suspect though, if they're willing to take the chance going back to their employers with a competing offer, they're at least willing to take that offer should their current employer react poorly or fail to match it.

Re:Some thoughts on asking for a raise by kelnos on Saturday October 18, 2014 @09:29AM (#8475281)
Ouch. I really hope I'm not a special case. I haven't worked anywhere that treated candidates like shit, and I haven't interviewed anywhere that did, either. Not saying places like that don't exist, but I really hope that's not the common case.
Re:Some thoughts on asking for a raise by x0x0 on Sunday October 19, 2014 @01:01AM (#8477261)

   I really don't think you should look for a competing offer unless you're 
   willing to accept that offer if you don't get what you want from your 
   current employer.
That mostly sounds like whining after you were handed a warm (or better!) prospect and screwed up the sale.

Also, unless you're one of the very very few companies that are honest in their job descriptions, offer a good work environment, and release the salary plus comp on offer at the beginning of the negotiation rather than the end, you're wasting a candidate's time just as much as he or she is wasting yours, if you choose to view it that way.

Re:Some thoughts on asking for a raise by vinceguidry on Sunday October 19, 2014 @04:15PM (#8479465)
> That mostly sounds like whining after you were handed a warm (or better!) prospect and screwed up the sale.

Would you shop around for a new job without any intention of taking it?

Re:Some thoughts on asking for a raise by x0x0 on Sunday October 19, 2014 @06:20PM (#8479849)
and you wonder why you have problems hiring

an engineer reaches out to you, and your reaction is, "Show me I'm not wasting my time"

Re:Some thoughts on asking for a raise by vinceguidry on Monday October 20, 2014 @01:03AM (#8480765)
You need to get straight who you're replying to. I'm not the guy who said he's having problems hiring. I'm somebody else. I've never hired anybody. I've only looked for jobs.

I'm asking you an honest question here. Would you, personally, engage another company about a job that you don't have the intention of taking, in order to gain leverage over your current company?

I can't see myself as being willing to do such a thing, but I'm interested in the thought processes of someone who would. Maybe I'm operating under false pretenses. You don't know unless you ask.

Re:Some thoughts on asking for a raise by x0x0 on Monday October 20, 2014 @04:47PM (#8484399)
And I'm asking you an honest question: if a prospect walks in your door, do you either (1) sell them, or (2) demand they prove they are in the market and aren't wasting your time. Maybe that person has a 5% chance of closing, or maybe they have a 90% chance. Nonetheless, when you go with the "prove you aren't wasting my time" plan, the probabilities plummet.
Re:Some thoughts on asking for a raise by vinceguidry on Monday October 20, 2014 @05:01PM (#8484465)
You are wasting my time right now by not answering my question. Good day sir.
Re:Some thoughts on asking for a raise by sheepmullet on Saturday October 18, 2014 @06:08AM (#8475054)
"I think in order to get to that point in your career where you can easily have multiple competing offers to choose from, you need to be a really good developer with a spiffy-looking portfolio."

Not true at all. Development is currently a hot market and you can get competing job offers right now without any portfolio as an average developer.

If you wait a few years development might not be such a great market and you might not get a raise even if you are a much better developer.

Re:Some thoughts on asking for a raise by kelnos on Saturday October 18, 2014 @07:30AM (#8475134)
I think this is framed the wrong way. I don't think most employers try to screw or underpay you, but they will -- quite rationally and reasonably -- avoid paying more for what they can have for less.

I'm sure there are some bad actors that try to keep their employees from figuring out what they're actually worth. The semi-recent revelations of no-poaching agreements between some high-profile tech companies certainly suggest that some do put a higher priority on retaining employees than they do on fair compensation.

But I really don't think that's the norm. I don't think many HR departments and managers sit around trying to come up with ways to keep their employees' salaries down. I hope I'm not being too idealistic thinking that.