If it weren't a meaningful protection, Freenet would have been shut down a long time ago, and all users arrested. Freenet's architecture seems like a reasonably good technical solution to a legal problem, by making it very difficult to distinguish between who requested data and who merely routed it.
But it's ludicrous for Whisper to deny that an IP address and timestamp isn't personally identifying information. To law enforcement or anyone else you have to worry about, it's close enough.
Can any lawyers versed in this area of the law comment on whether something like a phone can ever be "plausibly deniable" absent obvious evidence of theft?
Or comment on the concept of "plausible deniability" as a useful legal defense in general? I'm dubious that it offers any meaningful protection,