Re:Coanda Effect: Understanding Why Wings Work
by onedognight on Friday October 17, 2014 @08:32AM
(#8470592)
If you push an symmetric elongated body at a non-zero angle of attack in potential flow it will generate lift without (applying the Kutta condition to generate) circulation.
Re:Coanda Effect: Understanding Why Wings Work
by mannykannot on Saturday October 18, 2014 @09:49AM
(#8475306)
Perhaps your first paragraph explains why the Spitfire had thin wings. IIRC, one unintended consequence of this choice was that, as power and speed increased through WWII, the Spitfire avoided compressibility problems.
Over and above that, because the Coanda effect pertains to detached streams, it doesn't actually apply to a baseball, nor to wings. The author seems bright enough to handle potential flow calculations, and it would be a very instructive exercise for him to model a 2D flowfield around an airfoil without circulation, and then to input enough circulation to account for the Kutta condition at the trailing edge. I would advise using a "typical" cross section to avoid certain irregularities around the leading edge. Fundamentals of Aerodynamics, by Anderson, is a wonderful read, even if it is surprisingly infuriating to learn how hopelessly wrong typical aerodynamic intuitions are.
My fluids prof used to comment that people feel perfectly confident making pronouncements about aerodynamics where they'd be appalled to make the equivalently technical statements about brain surgery.