Re:HealthKit in depth from the perspective of a swimming app
by k-mcgrady on Thursday October 16, 2014 @09:28AM
(#8464734)
I wonder why these instruments are so hard to get right. I'll be interested to see how well the sensors on the Apple Watch work considering it's essentially the official companion to the Health app. I'd assume that monitoring heart rate form the wrist should be quite accurate but it probably depends on how tight someone has the watch on and the exact position it is on their arm.
Take for instance an elliptical machine I own (it's about 4-5x the price of the cheapest ones, so I guess we can call it "mid-range"). The heart-rate monitor on it is almost worse than useless. Sometimes it will report 200 BPM when I'm not holding the sensors. Sometimes it will under-report for long periods (e.g. reporting < 120 in the middle of a session, where I'm fairly confident my actual heart rate is around 150). I would not recommend relying on these things much.
That said, I think the general idea is not a bad one; we could definitely use more data to analyse. It's just that equipment that gets sold to the public is pretty erratic at the time of writing.