Re:Kicking the Bukkit: Anatomy of an open source meltdown
by sanderjd on Wednesday October 15, 2014 @12:52PM
(#8459678)
This is interesting, because I may have done this recently and I didn't think twice about it. I took someone else's patch (which had been submitted but never merged), merged it in to a newer version, fixed quite a few conflicts and tests, and committed it. Is that problematic? The original submitter's commits are intact and all the "fix-up" code is in the merge commit in my name. What if it is a rebase or cherry-pick where the commits themselves are re-written but retain the original submitter's name?
We are, however, very careful that all submissions are accepted under the original author's name. We rarely accept patches of the form "I took someone else's half-complete patch and fixed it up." In addition, all submissions are assumed to be released under the project's license. If the original submitter doesn't have permission to release their submission under that license, then the violated party should take that up with them.