News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by dcurtis on Saturday September 26, 2009 @11:03AM (#845556)
Who are you? Why does it seem like you're angry all the time?

I pointed out an observation. Your response used the word fuck and then called me lazy, which is extremely rude. Would you have said that to my face? This isn't personal, dude. I just get the same feeling now when scanning comments that I get when I am looking at products on Amazon and can't see the price.

Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by xenophanes on Saturday September 26, 2009 @01:54PM (#845781)
You got mad at him for making an impersonal remark, and now you say to him

"Who are you? Why does it seem like you're angry all the time?"

Which is an angry, personal remark.

The word "fuck", not directed at anyone, is not important. Personal attacks are.

If you don't like unalone's style, ignore him, don't psychologize him. Personally I appreciate the fact that he wrote substantive on-topic comments.

Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by moe on Saturday September 26, 2009 @07:00PM (#846240)
Sooo, when will we get pink, dancing polka dots to highlight conversations like this? :-)
Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by Confusion on Saturday September 26, 2009 @06:21PM (#846183)
You got mad at him for making an impersonal remark

I think Are you saying that you're too lazy to read what people are saying and form your own opinions? is a rather personal remark. A psychologizing one at that. Pot, meet kettle.

Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by unalone on Saturday September 26, 2009 @06:27PM (#846193)
If by "pot, meet kettle", you're mentioning how dcurtis responded to my remark with a personal psychologizing remark, then the expression makes sense; otherwise, I'm confused. I didn't get mad at what dcurtis said, so I don't know who's the pot and who's the kettle here.

"Are you saying that" is an opener that means, "How is it that you're viewing this, because I see it like this". I wasn't trying to be snide and put him down. I was letting him know that's how I was viewing the situation, and asking him his interpretation. It was also a teeny bit tongue-in-cheek, considering, again, he's currently spending a month of his life flying in planes.

Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by xenophanes on Sunday September 27, 2009 @02:02AM (#846586)
But he choose to highlight the profanity, not the remarks you point out. He told us which remark offended him, and it was an impersonal one.
Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by unalone on Saturday September 26, 2009 @11:16AM (#845576)
I'm an art student who is very rarely angry and doesn't think swearing indicates emotion. I also believe that it's better to have to spend time thinking about what to read, how to spend your time, than it is to be offered an easy way out that risks devaluing what people are saying. (I further believe that being called lazy usually isn't an insult.)

In person, I'd probably be doubly critical. Don't think of it as rude; I think criticizing what somebody's saying is a sign of respecting them. To quote a guy I'm in the middle of reading: "The more we love our friends, the less we flatter them; it is by excusing nothing that pure love shows itself."

If I were being rude, I'd ignore your comment and not call out what I thought was stupid/wrong about it. As it is, I'm debating what you said because I think there's a discussion to be had. For instance: Why would you feel the same reading comments as you would buying things? There's no harm to reading a few extra comments. You lose nothing but your time, which you're already spending on Hacker News.

Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by jrwoodruff on Saturday September 26, 2009 @01:01PM (#845706)
"Top-rated comments appear at the top of the thread"

True, but often times the top comment will not be the highest rated, but the reply or subsequent replies below the comment will be rated higher than the orginal post, but the entire thread gets moved to the top because of that.

Now I have no way of knowing that.

[edit] I also have no way of knowing when the MAJORITY of readers are disagreeing with me.

Up votes/down votes has always been a way to express yourself without commenting. If it's not visible, it's not as expressive, nor is it as rewarding to the commentor or the voter. I officially dislike this.

Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by unalone on Saturday September 26, 2009 @01:20PM (#845734)
I officially dislike disagreeing with somebody without explaining why. That's not what upvotes and downvotes were meant for. They're meant to maintain commenting relevancy by downvoting irrelevant comments. It's a brilliant idea dashed by the fact that most people would much rather downvote things they dislike and call it "democracy".
Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by jrwoodruff on Saturday September 26, 2009 @04:14PM (#845985)
Oh, I agree with that. I rarely downvote, and if/when I do I always leave a comment. It's more the opposite that I'm talking about here.

Someone may not down vote my comment, which, say, has 7 points. But they may leave a reply that is argumentative to my comment. With this new system, I can only see that my comment has 7 points, but I can't see that the counter-point reply to it may have 34.

The fact that many people are agreeing with the counter-point to my comment is significant, as is my inability to see that.

Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by jacquesm on Saturday September 26, 2009 @06:30PM (#846197)
> I also have no way of knowing when the MAJORITY of readers are disagreeing with me.

Why would that matter ? The majority isn't always right.

HN is not a popularity contest, but when you look at the comments that way it certainly starts to look like it.

Let's see what I can say that many people will agree with so I can be voted up ?

As unalone already remarked, now you have to make up your own mind about what you are reading, which is a huge improvement over the groupthink mentality. It forces you to think for yourself before casting your vote, it takes care of the huge feedback loop that was in HN before this change.

Even now, there is still some of that left, after all the sort order still tells you what the majority voted for, but that's subtle enough that it probably won't matter too much, and the new sorting algorithm seems to do a very good job of bringing the good stuff to the top.

Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by DanielBMarkham on Saturday September 26, 2009 @06:40PM (#846207)
Ok. This is starting to congeal for me.

What the old system did was to provide a numeric indicator of other readers' emotive participation in the discussion. It wasn't a popularity contest (although it could be for some) and it wasn't an agree/disagree rank (although it could be for some)

These "bad" uses of the score caused the system to get out of whack as more and more people participated. The problem is, there are "good" uses of the score, which is to use it as a way to filter the site. After all, there are thousands of comments added per hour and it's crazy to think that I'm going to have time to read every single one. I need an indicator of those comments that seem to affect the most number of readers because that's where I want to add my limited amount of effort.

I am not on a treasure hunt for good comments. I am not here to please PG or the other readers. Some might be but I am not. I am not jumping onboard to upvote things already upvoted -- the sad fact is that I can't read everything, so some things will have to have higher priority than others. If you take away the numeric system, I'll find some other way to filter -- perhaps by comment author or by scanning the front page for buzzwords that interest me.

I, the user, have a need to skim. Now the system can either easily provide that for me, or I'll probably go somewhere else. I don't mean that as a threat or anything -- I'm sure nobody gives a hoot where I read on the net or not -- but as an indication of the type of reaction the general public is going to have.

Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by jacquesm on Saturday September 26, 2009 @06:45PM (#846216)
> I, the user, have a need to skim

The sort order is what gives you exactly that, and that is still there, so the 'good' stuff is still at the top (and even better than before now with the improved sorting algorithm). It's just 'relative' now, instead of 'absolute'.

Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by DanielBMarkham on Saturday September 26, 2009 @06:49PM (#846225)
I'm trying to give it some time, jacquesm.

But right now I look at this thread and all I see is a bunch of jumbled-up comments. I don't know if the one at the top is worth-while for me to read or just matches some arcane criteria established by the programmer.

I'm forced to use "threads" to see where I've commented before and to use the new comments page to see where people are currently commenting. Any semblance of being able to apply my own sort criteria is gone.

And I think it gets to my ability to sort by my own criteria and the nested nature of the comments. Do I want to find highly-ranked comments under a lowly ranked parent? Sometimes those are the best ones.

I don't know. Let's see how it goes.

Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by pbhjpbhj on Monday September 28, 2009 @05:26PM (#849263)
HN is not a popularity contest

Yes it is.

Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by krschultz on Saturday September 26, 2009 @12:31PM (#845656)
That explains why you have so much time to read all the comments.

I don't have time to read all the comments so I'll look at the greatest hits. You can find the conversation based on the kharma scores, both positive and negative. If someone says something -4, it might be worth reading because it got such a reaction out of people. But a bunch of 1s and 2s on an old thread are noise that aren't worth reading.

Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by unalone on Saturday September 26, 2009 @12:35PM (#845663)
That explains why you have so much time to read all the comments.

What, that I'm a student? Reading comments doesn't take that long. As I said above: Fifteen minutes at most? And that's if it's a seriously long thread. Most threads are five minutes' skimming at most.

If someone says something -4, it might be worth reading because it got such a reaction out of people. But a bunch of 1s and 2s on an old thread are noise that aren't worth reading.

Not necessarily. Perhaps somebody made a brilliant comment, but only after people were done reading. In any case, that hasn't changed now: Top-rated comments appear at the top of the thread, same as always. So if you want the most "valued" conversations, read at the top.

Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by jacquesm on Saturday September 26, 2009 @06:40PM (#846205)
I take a lot longer to read a thread, but I think it is well worth it, even the downvoted comments sometimes contain really good stuff, and sometimes the downvotes are based on ambiguity or misunderstandings (or cultural gaps).

So if I pick a thread I read all of it, sometimes again at a later point in time (or via the 'threads' page).

Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by amalcon on Saturday September 26, 2009 @02:49PM (#845882)
I generally pick one or two most interesting topics from the front page, and read most of the comments on them. It seems better to read a few things in depth than reading sound bites on everything.

This also frees me of any need to complain about offtopic stuff, as long as a few on-topic posts remain.

Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by scott_s on Saturday September 26, 2009 @01:54PM (#845782)
Most people use swearing to indicate emotion. If you go against this convention, then you will often be misunderstood.
Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by unalone on Saturday September 26, 2009 @02:28PM (#845836)
That's why I try to be careful how I swear. I thought that "fuck that" was casual enough to come across as being neutrally dismissive. Guess not; apologies to all!
Re:Experiment: No Comment Scores by pyre on Saturday September 26, 2009 @09:37PM (#846379)
The problem is that in-person you can use body language and tone of voice to moderate the effects of using something like, "Fuck that!" but when you're expressing yourself completely in text you are at the whim of the reader's interpretation of your words.